Is Highland Park the next Restaurant Row?
A glut of new openings made us wonder if the north suburb could be the next big eating destination. With the help of Highland Park native Jill Weinberg, we came up with five reasons why it very well could be.
Wed May 16 2012
Photograph: Allison Williams
1 It has a travel-worthy burger.
Recently opened restaurant Benjamin (1849 Second St, Highland Park, 847-748-8737) serves thin slices of beef tongue with housemade giardiniera, and cedar-roasted salmon with yuzu-marmalade. But everyone comes here for the Benjamin Midwestern Wagyu beef burger, a monster of a sandwich that features caramelized red onions, thick bacon, smoked Gouda, heirloom tomato and—the burger’s best feature—Merkts cheddar cheese.
Jill says “I was very happy with my burger on the plank. But I did think $17 was a bit pricey for a burger.”
2 It’s attracting big-name chefs.
A few weeks ago, John des Rosiers opened his first HP spot, Moderno (1850 Second St, Highland Park, 847-433-8600). If you don’t know Des Rosiers, it’s because you don’t live in Lake Bluff, where his flagship restaurant, Inovasi, is located. But trust us—he’s a big name in the ’burbs, and a growing name in the city. Des Rosiers isn’t the only chef HP is attracting: Coming soon is In the Raw, a raw-foods restaurant that is “in partnership” with renowned chef Matthew Kenney.
Jill says “Moderno is a great addition to the neighborhood—I loved everything I ate. Special kudos to the agnolotti. Best I have ever had.”
3 It gets the fro-yo chains first. (And the gelato chains, too.)
Is it a coincidence that both Menchie’s (1929 Sheridan Rd, Highland Park, 847-780-4930), the pay-by-weight fro-yo chain from L.A., and Frost (617 Central Ave, Highland Park, 847-432-2233), the gelato chain from Arizona, both chose to open their first Illinois shops in Highland Park? Maybe. Or maybe HP residents are just crazed for icy sweets. Either way, the ’burb is first with frozen.
Jill says “Frost has become a neighborhood mecca to the point where I’m worried about my little Dairy Queen, because Dairy Queen was the gathering spot in Highland Park.”
4 It’s on top of the barbecue trend.
While Chicago was losing its mind over Lillie’s Q, Smoque and (to some degree) Chicago Q, Highland Park was focusing on its own ’cue: Real Urban Barbecue (610 Central Ave, Highland Park, 224-770-4227). Two Big Green Egg smokers outside the place suggest these guys aren’t messing around; the burnt-ends sandwich proves it.
Jill says “It has an ultra-casual atmosphere. Best thing on the menu is the burnt ends. But it hasn’t quite hit the mark where I am drawn to return again and again.”
5 It’s experiencing a sweets war.
Last spring, Turtle’s Cupcakes (469 Central Ave, Highland Park, 847-748-8627) opened in Highland Park’s downtown. A month later, Marla’s Sweet Bites (478 Central Ave, Highland Park, 847-432-4440) opened across the street. Both have stayed in business so far (though Marla’s recently cut its retail hours to weekends only), but neither is in the clear yet: Highland Pop (464 Central Ave, Highland Park, 847-433-4200), a Garrett-like popcorn shop, opened on the same block earlier this year.
Jill says “Two cupcake places that opened in Highland Park across the street from each other. It’s crazy!”