Susie’s Drive-in

Though this tiny 24-hour shack with a three-seater counter serves only two flavors of soft serve—vanilla and chocolate—it’s the 54 flavors of milkshakes that draw out folks at all hours. By throwing candy, cookies and flavored syrups into the blender, they create flavors like “baboon” (chocolate and banana), Oreo and strawberry shortcake—thick shakes that pair well with an order of chili-cheese fries and a burger at 4am.