"I agree to some extent with Katie.
I was fine with Depp, he's an amazeing actor and if he can pull of the vocals I look forward to what he's going to do with it. But casting his girfriend rubs me the wrong way. It feels like he just has a fall back cast and doesn't care much what the project is.
However I'm in love with Pattie LuPone's Lovette and there is no way anybody could replace her in my book, so I'm semi bias."