Shabd (2005)
Director: Leena Yadav
Movie review
From Time Out London
Former Booker Prize winner Shaukat (Dutt) hatches a plot to end his writer’s block: why not let his wife Antara (Rai) develop a relationship with her colleague Yash (Khan), who assumes she is single, and write a bestseller about the inevitable messy consequences? No prizes for guessing that events do not turn out as planned… An interesting delve by first-time female director Yadav into Fincher ‘reality game’ territory fails to engage as it lacks credibility from the outset due to serious miscasting, a resultant lack of chemistry between her leads, and an undue reliance on voiceovers and quirky graphics. Unforgivable is the illogical explanation advanced for Yash’s ignorance of the existence of Antara’s husband, given the Indian obsession with one’s marital status.Author: AS
Time Out London Issue 1799: February 9-16 2005
User reviews of this film
-
- ash said...
- Posted on Jul 06 2008 06:54 One of those offbeat movies with a theme unacceptable to India. Otherwise a lovely performance by aishwarya rai
- Report as inappropriate
Most popular on this site
Features
Street fighting men
BAM celebrates John Carpenter’s sci-fi-inflected rage against the machine.
Zoom in:
<em>They Live'</em>s Roddy Piper
The American experience
British comedian Steve Coogan gets in touch with his inner Yank in <em>Hamlet 2.</em>
Spanish intuition
Scarlett Johansson and Rebecca Hall flirt away an Iberian summer in <em>Vicky Cristina Barcelona.</em>
Shadows and frogs
Crime pays in Film Forum’s expansive French noir series.
Strip tease
IFC’s new midnight-movie series revisits Hollywood’s groovy ’60s scene.
To air is human
<em>Man on Wire,</em> a new doc about a surreal Manhattan morning, aims high.




What do you think?
Post your review now