Film
What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases
Beyond Bollywood
Anil Sinanan on a season showcasing the lost side of Indian cinema.
Sep 6 2006
If one asks 'the man on the Clapham omnibus', or even the average British Asian, what they know about Indian film, the answer is most likely to be 'Bollywood'. These camp, candyfloss song-and-dance melodramas have become synonymous with Indian cinema in recent years. Although there is much to enjoy in these 'masala' movies, India does not have a reputation for experimental, thought-provoking movies. This is a misconception. Alternative cinema has always been made in India – just think of the films of Satyajit Ray, Guru Dutt, Ritwik Ghatak, Shyam Benegal – but they remain largely unseen and unknown, mostly because Indian audiences, domestic and foreign, traditionally don't like seeing the reality of their daily lives portrayed on screen. To redress the balance, next weekend Tate Modern's 'Cinema of Prayoga' season offers features, shorts and documentaries of such 'parallel' cinema.
The Sanskrit word 'Prayoga' loosely translates as 'experiment' or 'representation', and it is hoped that these screenings will expose new audiences to the rich vein of visual-arts cinema that confirms that not all Indian cinema conforms to the Bollywood norm.
Kicking off the weekend on Friday September 15 is a rare screening of a sequence from 'Raja Harishchandra', regarded as the first Indian movie. This silent black-and-white classic, made in 1913 by Dhundiraj Govind Phalke, is loosely based on the great Hindu epic, the Mahabharata. It tells the story of King Harishchandra, played by Phalke, who accidentally invades the space of a sadu (holy man) and consequently has to renounce his kingdom and suffer numerous hardships before his atonement.
It can be read as a critique of British imperialism of the time and a proud statement of Indian cultural values, and the film's success led directly to the establishment of an Indian film industry with Hindi cinema (embryonic Bollywood) taking the lead. What makes the film unique is Phalke's technique in creating mood and continuity through the juxtaposition of spatial planes, allowing the viewer an insight into the events unfolding. Sadly, this is the only surviving reel that remains from the original print. The season will also include a series of excerpts from Phalke's incomplete films ('Birth of Shree Krishna'), along with others made by like-minded filmmakers of the period.
Other highlights include the 'Saturday Live Mumbai' presentation 'Migration and [Dis]location', showcasing contemporary films from the hip and happening Mumbai cultural scene, including several films by NRI (Non-Resident Indian) directors who have returned to India to explore their cultural identity. Highly recommended is Xav Leplae's 'I'm Bobby', a re-imagining of Raj Kapoor's classic 1973 'Romeo and Juliet'-style Bolly-hit 'Bobby'. Sunday's main feature, 'Kaal Abhirati' ('Addiction to Time'), a homage to the Phalke style of filmmaking, is also worth catching.
The festival closes on Tuesday 19 with a series of groundbreaking shorts. Best of the bunch is 'Bomgay', a collection of six short films depicting gay life in Mumbai (yes, it exists). Made in 1996, this 12-minute film reveals the pitfalls of being gay in India's 'maximum city', where homosexuality remains illegal.
As Bollywood's profile in London continues to grow, this festival is a timely reminder that not all Indian filmmakers sing from the same sheet. Go see – just don't expect any saucy wet-sari musical sequences.
'Cinema of Prayoga: Indian Experimental Film and Video 1913-2006' runs Sept 15-19 at Tate Modern.
User comments on this story
-
- Nirmal said...
-
I disagree that Bomgay tells nothing about homosexuality in Bombay. It is an interpretation of various aspects of gay life - esp if you notice the short 'Friends'. It is beautiful.
Since Bomgay there have been several Indian films on homosexuality - Onir's 'My Brother Nikhil', Sridhar Rangayan's 'Gulabi Aaina', 'Yours Emotionally', Ashish Sawhney's 'Happy Hookers' , lesbian film 'Sancharam' and many more. It is just that there have not been much exposure to these wonderful films.
Many of them have not been released because of strict laws and crazy censor rules in india, but their DVDs are available on Amazon.
Hope things change for the better soon. Posted on Feb 25 2008 18:10 - Report as inappropriate
-
- bhavesh said...
- hi frd how r u Posted on Sep 20 2006 12:42
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Prashant Singh said...
-
The above article certainly shows how little these so-called experts on Indian Cinema. Bollywood is no longer a haunt of old-school directors who used to feature 'saucy-wet sari' sequences in thier films.Nowadays Indian film industry does not only cover Bollywood productions. There are different more artistic styles and currents that can be found in India. More and more real-life films are being produced and deal with today’s problems including even homosexuality, a topic still wrapped in taboos. India has today about 60 million fluent English speaking inhabitants representing a special segment though their overall importance is relatively small yet.
A growing number of directors are releasing films which are relevent to the modern India, tackling issues like drugs,forced marrieges , homosexuality and last but not the least the liberal youth culture of India.
Bomgay was shot a decade ago and infact tells nothing about homosexuality in Mumbai , except depicting it as as a sexual preference of middle aged pervs looking for a quickie in Mumbai's public toilets.
The series was shot by a wannabe director looking for a contraversial topic and armed with a non-existing script along with really bad camera work.
Mumbai has grown both in prosperity and outlook towards topic like homosexuality since Bomgay was shot and a critic citing it as the 'groundbreaking shorts' certainly didn't hear about the Deepa Mehta's 'Fire'.
Sad to see that the writer is an Asian, obviously warped in his own little world where the only Indian cinema he gets to see are the one's with saucy wet-sari musical sequences. Posted on Sep 07 2006 14:42 - Report as inappropriate
Top Stories
Ridley Scott interview
Director Ridley Scott tells Cath Clarke why he's making a science fiction comeback
Cannes Film Festival 2012: half-time report
Dave Calhoun reports on the hits, misses and a shocking new masterpiece from Michael Haneke








What do you think?
Post your comment now