Film
What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases
Cannes: Day Eight
Get the Time Out opinion of one of the most controversial films of the festival so far.
May 18 2005
There are few certainties in life, but the controversy surrounding a new Lars von Trier film is definitely one.
'Manderlay' is the Danish director's follow-up to 'Dogville' and the second in a trilogy of 'American' films. I say 'American' because 'Manderlay', like 'Dogville' before it, is about as American as foie gras.
It's certainly an American story about a young woman, Grace, who stumbles across a slave colony in 1930s America.
On the death of its mistress (Lauren Bacall), Grace assumes a leadership that she uses to impose her own brand of emancipation on the slaves.
The parallels with the recent American mission in Iraq are clear, especially when Grace's ideas of freedom prove to be highly questionable in terms of morality and taste.
Von Trier plays with the idea of emancipation to provoke a debate on America's current ideas of 'democracy'.
But it's a stilted and often tedious affair as John Hurt's voiceover leads us through eight Brechtian chapters.
The approach is identical to 'Dogville': everything is filmed on a largely bare sound stage with chalk markings denoting buildings and incorporating minimal sets. The lighting is simple. A large, ever-present cast acts as a chorus to the main action. The photography is intimate and hand-held.
However, the excitement of von Trier's experimental approach is lost with this second film, leaving just a troubled and troubling story.
It's hard to knock von Trier; his method is intellectually sound and pleasingly original - but his message is lost in unappealing dialogue and frankly dull exposition.
He overloads the film with so many conflicting ideas and internal debates that his argument is hard to follow or even understand.
The credits roll again to David Bowie's 'Young Americans' and this time reveal a montage of images relating to the black experience.
But it doesn't feel like we've just watched a summation of that experience, only a clumsy – if challenging – dance on its margins.
At the press conference for the film, von Trier answered the inevitable question about a Dane who has never visited America tackling the country head-on.
'America is a good subject because such a big, big part of our lives has to do with America,' he said.
'America is kind of sitting on the world, there's no question about it. And therefore I'm making films that have to do with America, because America fills about 60% of my brain. All the words in there, all the things I've experienced in my life, about 60% of them – and I'm not very happy about that – is American.
'So in fact I am American, but I can't go there to vote, I can't change anything because I'm from a small country. And that is why I make films about America. I don't think it's so strange.'
For more Cannes stories, click here
Most popular on this site
Top Stories
Hippies who work for The Man
To celebrate George Clooney comedy 'The Men who Stare at Goats', we look back at six memorable onscreen hippies who fought the system from within
Roland Emmerich's guide to disaster movies
Ahead of the release of '2012', Roland Emmerich offers his ten tips on creating the perfect global catastrophe
Grant Heslov: interview
Grant Heslov, director of 'The Men who Stare at Goats' talks about his old pal George Clooney, his interest in the paranormal, and his fond memories of working on 'Happy Days'
The Coen brothers discuss 'A Serious Man'
Masters of contrary comedy, Joel and Ethan Coen have struck gold again with their latest, ‘A Serious Man’
Ten inspirations behind 'Avatar'?
Time Out ponders the influences behind James Cameron's anticipated space-opera on the basis of the trailer
Michael Jackson's This Is It: review
Kenny Ortega's posthumous concert film is a rousing eulogy for one of pop's great enigmas
Michael Haneke: The man behind the menace
From Cannes to Munich to London, Dave Calhoun tours Michael Haneke's Palme d'Or winner, 'The White Ribbon'
Lone Scherfig talks 'An Education'
Danish director Lone Scherfig was an unlikely choice for a very English affair like 'An Education'. Cath Clarke meets her
How Jane Campion brought John Keats back to life
Time Out gets Romantic with the ‘difficult’ New Zealander about her new film, 'Bright Star'
Time Out's 50 greatest animated films with commentary by Terry Gilliam
In celebration of the release of Pixar's 'Up' and Wes Anderson's 'Fantastic Mr Fox', read our rundown of fifty classic feature length animations












What do you think?
Post your comment now