Dear Frankie (2004)
Director: Shona Auerbach
Movie review
From Time Out London
Frankie (Jack McElhone) is a young deaf boy who lives with his mum, Lizzie (Emily Mortimer), and grandma, Nell (Mary Riggans), in a small flat close to the Glasgow docks. The trio, we learn, are forever on the move, always on the run from Frankie’s abusive father, Davey, who is trying to track them down. Lizzie, however, has concocted a very different version of events to protect Frankie. She claims that his dad is a sailor on a globe-touring ship, HMS Accra, even going to the extravagant lengths of replying to her son’s filial missives herself, ingeniously employing a local PO box number and foreign stamps. This neat conspiracy hits the rocks, though, when – would you Adam and Eve it – the local paper announces that the real HMS Accra will soon be docking in Glasgow. Thank God, then, for a friend’s anonymous brother (Gerard Butler), a mercenary sort who is willing to pretend to be Frankie’s father for a couple of days. Of course, things don’t go to plan…This is a strange mix of social realism – the Glasgow setting, the single mother, lots of fish ’n’ chips – and shameless, soppy plot contrivance, even if good performances and calm camerawork serve to keep some check on an overbearing sentimentality that threatens to engulf you at every turn (driven by a signposting soundtrack). In the end, Lizzie’s terrible lie is unsatisfactorily explained in the hope that the audience will be too teary to notice. Another question is left begging too: why is Frankie deaf? Sure, a local reason is revealed in the story, but it’s hard not to feel that giving Frankie a disability is just another, unnecessary way of eliciting even more sympathy for the poor little blighter.
Author: DC
Time Out London Issue 1796: January 19-26 2005
Cast & crew
Director: Shona Auerbach
Producer: Caroline Wood
Cast: Emily Mortimer, Gerard Butler, Sharon Small, Jack McElhone, Mary Riggans
Duration: 103 mins
Most popular on this site
Features
Street fighting men
BAM celebrates John Carpenter’s sci-fi-inflected rage against the machine.
Zoom in:
<em>They Live'</em>s Roddy Piper
The American experience
British comedian Steve Coogan gets in touch with his inner Yank in <em>Hamlet 2.</em>
Spanish intuition
Scarlett Johansson and Rebecca Hall flirt away an Iberian summer in <em>Vicky Cristina Barcelona.</em>
Shadows and frogs
Crime pays in Film Forum’s expansive French noir series.
Strip tease
IFC’s new midnight-movie series revisits Hollywood’s groovy ’60s scene.
To air is human
<em>Man on Wire,</em> a new doc about a surreal Manhattan morning, aims high.




What do you think?
Post your review now