Film

Movie theaters, reviews and showtimes in New York, plus articles, trailers and more

 

The Women (2008)

Director: Diane English

2

Critics' rating

Average user rating
No reviews

Movie review

From Time Out New York

Diane English’s abysmal remake of George Cukor’s 1939 femme classic will have fans of the original growing claws. This summer’s success of Sex and the City proved that, yes, those with ovaries like to go to the movies, and sped up the release date of English’s film, which had languished for years. For all of SATC’s failings, it at least had dialogue that could conceivably be heard on Fifth Avenue. Unsteadily directing for the first time, English (a creator of Murphy Brown) also wrote the screenplay, sucking all the venom and verve out of Anita Loos and Jane Murfin’s adaptation of Clare Boothe Luce’s play and trading it for Oprah-lite homilies, group hugs and, astonishingly, testimonials by the cast after the end credits roll.

Updating the basic premise of the original—a selfless moneyed mother and wife (Ryan) finds out that her husband is having an affair; some friends help and some sabotage—English favors lines like “How could I share myself with you if I didn’t know who I was?” over the witty, rapid-fire banter between Cukor’s actresses. Though they bore the masks of several layers of Max Factor, the visages of Cukor’s cast still moved; not so Ryan’s ghastly trout pout. Jokes about plastic surgery abound in the remake, which seem all the more cruel or clueless considering the great difficulty Ryan has in making basic facial expressions. This is not to suggest that gay men, like Cukor and SATC’s Michael Patrick King, make better women’s films—only that those blessed with XX chromosomes aren’t necessarily the best equipped to make comedies marketed to them.

Author: Melissa Anderson 2008-09-09 17:25:53

Time Out New York Issue 676: September 11 - 17, 2008


  • Print this page
  • Send to a friend

What do you think?
Post your review now

clear rating
Min 1 star. Zero stars will be treated as unrated.

*mandatory fields


Cast & crew

Director: Diane English

Cast: Meg Ryan, Annette Bening, Debra Messing, Jada Pinkett Smith

Rated: PG-13

Duration: 114 mins

US Release: Sep 12 2008




Features

Making a name for himself

Making a name for himself

Sin Nombre's Cary Joji Fukunaga learned his lessons well.

To the letter

Forty years later, Costa-Gavras's Z still brims with fury.

Mind over matter

David Cronenberg reflects on a most bizarre body: his own corpus of work.

Fool's gold

Can an Oscar win lead to a cursed career? Here are five stories of postaward professional meltdowns.

We are the championed

Terrorists and teens abound in this year's "Film Comment Selects."

A history of violence

Matteo Garrone's kaleidoscopic Gomorrah wallops you with Italy's crime crisis.

True romantic

James Gray exchanges urban amorality for amour in Two Lovers.

Playing in the dark

MoMA salutes pianist Stuart Oderman's 50 years as the one-man sound of silents.

Junk bonds

Cast and crew recall the making of the classic NYC drug drama The Panic in Needle Park.