Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Assault on Precinct 13 (2005)

Average user rating

2 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

So why remake John Carpenter’s claustrophobic ’70s urban siege classic, with Ethan Hawke and Laurence Fishburne standing in for Austin Stoker and Darwin Joston? Why Not: the name of Richet’s production company says it all. Like Jonathan Demme’s version of ‘The Manchurian Candidate’, this uses the original more as a backbone than the full skeleton, with the director blurring roles, moving locations and switching names, but maintaining the central principle (itself familiar from Hawks’ ‘Rio Bravo’): one cop and one robber, plus sundry other mismatched suckers, are holed up in an abandoned police station, while outside a gang of well-organised, well-armed ne’er-do-wells make like Romero’s zombies and prepare to tear them limb from limb.

The original spooled with the dynamic of a Nirvana song: clammy calm punctuated by extreme violence, underscored by Carpenter’s Suicide-meets-Vangelis theme. Where Carpenter’s heroes, Bishop and Wilson, were little more than charismatic ciphers, Richet accords his leads plenty of backstory and opens out the plot as he manoeuvres his ten or so characters (among them Maria Bello, Ja Rule and Brian Dennehy) into the police station where they can be whittled down one by one. The scenes within the besieged building are strongest, a solid blend of paranoia, humour and sudden death, making the decision to book-end the picture with extended sequences shot in the great outdoors all the stranger (almost as daft, in fact, as the notion to locate a police station within the secluded confines of a large pine forest). At its best, though, this is witty, tense and bloody: a homage that Carpenter might appreciate.

Author: PW

Time Out London Issue 1797: January 26-February 2 2005

Email Tweet Share

User reviews of this film

Malcolm Davey said...

Posted on Apr 22 2012 08:38 atmospheric setting, strong cast and incomparably beautiful Bello just about keep this watchable until it descends into routine shoot-em-up

Report as inappropriate
Leona Luk said...

Posted on Jul 28 2007 16:44 Not better than the original, however still a very tight, suspenseful film that is chock full of celebs. This is very fun to watch and only has one plot related problem. The bad guys outside the police station are soon revealed to be corrupt cops, and it appears that they are using police equipment (even a helicopter) to get inside the building. Their grand plan is to blame a gang of baddies, however how can they explain their intense use of ammo and loss of fellow corrupt cops in the morning? It looks like they've got about a hundred corrupt cops sieging the building, including SWAT...how many corrupt cops are there in Detroit?
If you agree to not question the film with what I think are logical questions, then the film is quite enjoyable, fun, nicely paced.

Report as inappropriate