Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

The Beat That My Heart Skipped (2005)

Average user rating

No reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

Jacques Audiard (‘A Self-Made Hero’, ‘Read My Lips’) translates to modern-day Paris the dilemmas of James Toback’s 1978, New York-set ‘Fingers’ – the story of a young man caught between art and crime, between his own ambitions and those of his father – in an audacious move that reverses the old chestnut that you should ignore the remake and hunt down the original instead. In place of Harvey Keitel’s Jimmy Fingers, Audiard gives us 28-year-old Thomas Seyr (Romain Duris), an archetypal slick and streetwise Parisian – always immaculately suited and booted – and a man who is in perpetual conflict with himself as the victim of a dual, contrasting inheritance from his wheeler-dealer father, Thomas (Niels Arestrup) and his late concert-pianist mother, Sonia. When we first encounter Thomas, he is very much his father’s boy – he works as a heavy-handed employee of a dodgy property firm – but a chance encounter with a piano teacher, an old acquaintance of his mother, leads to an offer of an audition and a decision by Thomas to turn his back on the manhandling of wayward tenants and instead prepare himself for a career in music. Thomas hires a Vietnamese piano teacher, Miao Lin (Linh Dan Pham), but his impatience and brash manner mean that he approaches piano lessons as he does real-estate – as a hustler.‘You gonna make dough from pianos?’ asks one of Thomas’s sceptical colleagues. ‘Not pianos. The piano,’ Thomas snaps back, yet his new ambition never really convinces. Rather, like the ill-defined sexual encounters that Thomas enjoys with his friend’s wife, the piano is an experiment, a means for Thomas to attempt to redefine his place in the world. Audiard’s nuanced (and very well-performed, especially by Duris) character study is ultimately about fathers and the shadow they throw over their sons’ lives. The film’s opening scene depicts a friend of Thomas analysing his own relationship with his ageing dad (‘You wake up one morning and you’ve switched places’). In retrospect, it stands as a prologue to Audiard’s intelligent study of Thomas’s own life.

Author: DC

Time Out London Issue 1837: November 2-9 2005

Email Tweet Share