Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

Hidden Blade (2004)

Director: Yoji Yamada

Average user rating

1 review

Movie review

From Time Out London

Most famous as the helmer of the Japanese movie institution ‘Tora-san’ – a 48-film series of nostalgic comedy-dramas that ran from 1969 to 1995 – the septuagenarian Yamada Yoji is evidently not afraid of repeating himself. His latest samurai melodrama, the highly enjoyable ‘Hidden Blade’, reworks many of the same themes and narrative forms of his recent Oscar-nominated ‘Twilight Samurai’, but it’s so fluently directed, well acted and emotionally satisfying that its lack of originality can be forgiven.

‘Mystery Train’’s Masatoshi Nagase gives a dignified and moving performance as Munezo, the honorable samurai of a backwater town who has carried a torch from late childhood for the lower-caste Kie (Takako Matsu), since married into a merchant family of Dickensian meanness. Yamada elaborates the changing military stance of the 1860s Tokugawa Shogunate – lots of comic business involving English rifles and Dutch cannon – but his heart lies in the distended romantic entanglement of Munezo and Kie, pushing the couple’s portrait of emotionally self-denying forebearance to the edge of Sirkian melodrama.

On the whole, however, Yamada does not succumb to stylistic flourish. Mutsuo Naganuma’s fine period cinematograpy is typically unostentatious and the climactic, cathartic action sequences are notable for their own form of realism: when Munezo is instructed by a corrupt senior retainer to kill an old friend, sentenced to a fate worse than hara-kiri for his Western-ising views, their confrontation is filmed to emphasise our quiet hero’s deep ambivalence toward violence. It’s old-fashioned fare, certainly, but only Isao Tomita’s string-based score rams that home.

Author: WH 2005-11-29 11:34:29

Time Out London Issue 1841: November 30-December 7 2005

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Technoguy said...

Posted on Jan 12 2008 16:26 This film like Yamada's last is similar to a fully matured wine. The scenes are easy on the eye,full bodied,fluid and beautiful to behold.The characters of different castes are believable.The hero, a Samurai uses his sword only as a last resort,maybe once or twice in his life,saying to his future wife,currently his servant ,he's never killed anyone.He is ordered by a corrupt senior to kill an old friend.He tries to find a way out of this but he has to do it in the end.He finally gives up the Samurai way of life and escapes from the caste system which forbids him marrying the only woman he's ever loved.There 's so much good humour involved and a whole world ofcourtesy and subtlety,but hara kiri for those who fall foul.

Report as inappropriate