Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

The Departed (2006)

Director: Martin Scorsese

Average user rating

2 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

‘Infernal Affairs’, the 2002 Hong Kong crime thriller that pitched a Triad mole in the police force against an undercover cop in the mob, finds its reflection in ‘The Departed’. We’ve moved to Irish Boston, where hotheaded rookie Billy Costigan (Leonardo DiCaprio) is ostensibly turfed out of the force as a cover for his long-term assignment, while ambitious hood Colin Sullivan (Matt Damon) signs up for the State Police Academy and speedy promotion. Their respective controls are police Captain Queenan (Martin Sheen) and capo Frank Costello (Jack Nicholson).

William Monahan’s screenplay retains the basic architecture, and several bits of business, from the original, pepping it up with snappy macho banter, including some of the most gloriously expressive swearing this side of David Mamet; senior officers Alec Baldwin and Mark Wahlberg spark off each other like an obscene double act. But it’s somewhat distended; it’s two decades since Scorsese made a feature less than two hours long, and he shows no sign of belt-tightening. The simple, mathematical tragedy of ‘Infernal Affairs’ is mussed by extra layers of hierarchy on both sides and a frustratingly over-seasoned climax.

The casting, however, is quite a coup. There’s still something boyish about both Damon and DiCaprio, and both do best as characters who play make-believe but get lost in the game (see ‘The Talented Mr Ripley’ and ‘Catch Me If You Can’). Here they approach their impostors from different ends of the spectrum: DiCaprio’s Costigan starts out an agitated loner and gets more tightly wound, while Damon makes Sullivan cocky, relaxed, one of the guys. For a truly laidback performance, though, look no further than Nicholson. ‘I don’t wanna be a product of my envi-o-ment, I want my envi-o-ment to be a product of me,’ his opening voice-over drawls – and boy, does he get it. He’s every inch the big cat in his dotage, pulling rat-faces and pratfalls in a bar, grandstanding in a porn theatre. The man’s a movie star and it’s a ridiculously enjoyable spectacle, but it feels more like Jack holding court on Oscar night than a crime lord about his work.

You wonder if ‘The Departed’ may have been more fun to make than to watch; at any rate, its pleasures lie in the way it permits us membership of the gang – not that homophobic ribaldry and gags with severed hands are everyone’s idea of fun. There’s a hint of self-pastiche on Scorsese’s part, a suspicion that he’s appealing to past successes. But few directors can compose a movie with the power, grace and assurance that Scorsese brings to each shot and scene, and ‘The Departed’ is more fun, and certainly more funny, than his last few films. Probe it for more than back-slapping entertainment, however, and you might start to smell a rat.

Author: Ben Walters 2006-10-03 10:59:03

Time Out London Issue 1885: October 4-11 2006

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Justin Berkovi said...

Posted on May 15 2009 22:27 The original is a great film. For me this is one of Scorsese's worst ever films. Sure the cast is great but the whole thing runs like something of a joke. The characters just don't have the gravitas of his previous films and in all it seems like big names just going through the motions.
Disappointing even after many viewings.

Report as inappropriate
Technoguy said...

Posted on Jan 10 2008 22:34 This was a solidly casted professional job and very entertaining with it.Having Jack Nicholson in the cast fired it up as a shoe-in for the oscars.Also the casting of the two moles in each camp,Damon and Dicapprio proved a winner.What a star turn too from Mark Walberg.Marti deserved the oscar yes,but he's learned to play the game now.This is a long way down the mountain from Mean Streets,Taxi Driver,Raging Bull and Goodfellas.I still preferred the original. A remake is still a remake.

Report as inappropriate