Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

The Other Boleyn Girl (2008)

Director: Justin Chadwick

Time Out rating

Average user rating

32 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

Why in the name of ermine boleros would anyone make such a dull, coy and, worst of all, pretty film about Anne Boleyn? Writer Peter Morgan (‘The Queen’, ‘The Last King of Scotland’) again ventures into the parlours of the rich and powerful to excavate a crisis. This time it’s the marital and succession woes of Henry VIII (Eric Bana) and their knock-on effects on two noble sisters, Anne and Mary Boleyn, who are vying for the eye of a broody king, egged on by their father (Mark Rylance) and their scheming uncle, Thomas Howard (David Morrissey, playing Alastair Campbell to Rylance’s Blair).

It’s no doubt a producer’s wet dream to cast Scarlett Johansson and Natalie Portman as the two Boleyn girls. Johansson is the domestically-inclined Mary (‘What about our future in the country?’ she grumbles in Good Housekeeping fashion to her drippy husband) and Portman (more successfully) is the more forthright Anne, newly and unconvincingly emboldened by a spell at the French court (it’s a small mercy she doesn’t return with a copy of ‘The Second Sex’ under her arm).

The pair’s stellar presence at least fits the film’s Holbein-meets-Annie Leibovitz colour palette; let’s call it the Vanity Fayre look.Polite, well-made, adequately performed, moderately paced – television director Justin Chadwick’s take on Philippa Gregory’s racy, trashy novel is everything you don’t want it to be. Morgan’s script is workable if skeletal and possessed of some odd turns of speech (‘Would you accept the challenge?,’ Howard asks Anne, imitating a gameshow host as he pushes her towards Henry).

The film takes itself too seriously (see the literal dark clouds over the palace) and never ignites as it should in a storm of rivalries, fear, sex and religion. There’s a 15-minute period of paranoia as Anne’s relationship with Henry (a brooding Bana, sidelined) falls to pieces and you wish there was more of this. Where are the sparks? The dirt? The sex? And where’s Cardinal Wolsey while we’re at it? Most memorable are the costumes.

Author: Dave Calhoun 2008-03-03 17:15:17

Time Out London Issue 1959 March 5 – 11 2008

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

freya said...

Posted on Mar 08 2008 09:49 I think the reviewer misses the point of Justin Chadwicks production. It is a fairy tale and really good fun. However, if he wants to see a dark, visceral, dirty, sexy, fabulous, cool, daring, innovative version of The Other Boleyn Girl he should get hold of a copy of the highly acclaimed BBC TV version which starred Jodhi May and Natasha Macelhone and Jared Harris - all who give stunning performances. This exceptional film, made on a tiny budget, is much more sophisticated and truly gripping. The critics loved it. Let's hope it comes out on dvd here as it is in the states.

Report as inappropriate
arnold hunt said...

Posted on Mar 07 2008 15:50 The bad tempered review above by dave calhoun does not begin to do justice to the quality of this film. All right there may be no 'sparks, dirt or sex' - well it is restrained even understated but many of the most formidable emotions are best delineated thus. In fact everyone acts their socks off and the performances are uniformly thrilling - even the smaller parts for example when hapless queen catherine passes the two sisters in one of the corridors of court and remarks 'Ah! the Boleyn whores' I defy anyone not to be moved at her humiliation. How absurd that your reviewer should think the film would be improved by the presence of cardinal wolsey! the film is about the two sisters for heavens sake.
See it - once you are over the first few minutes in which there are some glaring anachronisms of dialogue it is a marvellous thing.

Report as inappropriate