Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

Vicky Cristina Barcelona (2008)

Director: Woody Allen

Time Out rating

Average user rating

29 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

Woody Allen’s European tour heads south to Spain for a funny, lusty film that will have fans breathing a sigh of relief after the embarrassing gulf between intention and reality that was ‘Cassandra’s Dream’. A little distance goes a long way: while Allen’s cock-eyed attempts to infiltrate the greasy spoons of Kentish Town in his last film or the country houses of the Home Counties in ‘Match Point’ proved too much for British audiences, most will be happy to swallow the Spanish and Catalan clichés – Gaudí, Miró, long-haired lotharios with guitars – that Allen lays on liberally in return for a light, witty, sexy exchange of views on flirting, relationships, commitment and the ongoing clash of lifestyles in the old and new worlds.

It helps Allen’s cause that his story is about Americans in Europe: two graduates, Vicky (Rebecca Hall) and Cristina (Scarlett Johansson) – one dark-haired, sensible and engaged to a humourless, chino-fancying financier, the other blonde, instinctive and single – arrive in Barcelona to spend the summer at the home of expat friends of Vicky’s family.

The pair’s conflicting attitudes to life and love are challenged by a gift from the Spanish gods: Javier Bardem is Juan Antonio Gonzales, an artist whose looks and lifestyle typify Allen’s perverse, tongue-in-cheek idea of the wild Latin temperament. When Juan suggests a weekend away in Oviedo and, maybe, some love-making (Vicky scoffs, Cristina pants) a love triangle emerges that not only highlights and upsets Vicky and Cristina’s differing ideals but also lumps them together in the same camp when the triangle morphs into a square: enter Juan Antonio’s hot-headed ex-wife Maria Elena, played by Penélope Cruz, who makes even Cristina look like a nun sucking lemons. Allen seems to be saying: Americans, get over yourselves. Our sympathies are squarely with the free-living and loving attitude of Juan Antonio over Vicky’s uptight mask or the drippy attitudes of her fiancé Doug (Chris Messina), who arrives mid-film.
The script is witty and playful, the casting just right: Hall and Johansson make for a warm contrast and Cruz and Bardem are more than willing to indulge Allen’s Spanish fantasies while running with the comedy of their characters’ love-hate relationship. Cruz only appears halfway, but Allen sets her up brilliantly with Bardem dropping mysterious mention of his fiery ex into every other sentence.

Exploring the mystery of what makes intelligent men and women tick in harmony and disharmony is what Allen does best, and so we’re back in the territory of ‘Husbands and Wives’ or ‘Hannah and Her Sisters’ with this jaunt, which neither takes itself too seriously nor wastes its ideas with sloppy craftmanship, both of which have upset his plans before.
The film has a pleasing pace, using voiceover to hop between scenes, some of which are mere tableaux. There’s no Allen or Allen alter-ego in this film, although we hear his puppeteer’s voice: ‘If you don’t start undressing me soon, this is going to turn into a panel discussion,’ breathes Cristina to Juan. ‘Let’s not get into one of these categorical imperative arguments,’ pleads Doug, summoning the ghost of Allen marching through Manhattan with Diane Keaton. After a hiccup at immigration, Allen can keep his passport – for now.

Author: Dave Calhoun 2009-02-03 10:56:42

Time Out London Issue 2007, 5 - 11 Feb, 2009

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Jane Allen said...

Posted on Aug 31 2009 13:11 Banal, vapid, trite, passe: pre- not post-modern. Penelope Cruz's "supporting actress" award was well earned, but there was nothing to support. Johannsen was a wet dish-cloth in comparison. About as subtle as a disney movie, as deep as a saucer of sour milk, with a cop-out narration to boot. Avoid!

Report as inappropriate
Michael said...

Posted on Jul 01 2009 20:09 How can anyone say this a bad film, i think to many people have gotten use to "guns" & "violence" look deeper into the film and you will see what i , and many others seen. Magic film :)

Report as inappropriate
Richard said...

Posted on Mar 11 2009 03:17 Even worse than the execrable Match Point - Woody Allen has used up his nine lives. The voice-over was so irritating and inane. None of the characters were particularly interesting, bar Penelpe Cruz's Maria. It was smug and condescending towards Americans for their supposed materialism - the contrast with the caricature of cultured, sophisticated artistic Europeans was very subtle. Woody still wanting to be Bergman, I guess. And the menage a trois? More late middle-aged fantasies. Vicky is doing a Master's in Catalan identity but can't speak a word of the language. Well, of course.

Report as inappropriate
DV said...

Posted on Mar 09 2009 14:15 My mistake, Allen fans; his new film premieres next month, April 22 NYC.

Report as inappropriate
DV said...

Posted on Mar 09 2009 14:08 Pretty good for a recent Woody film, although it's a shame he has lost his flair for screwball comedy. But then he is about 80; aren't people allowed to change style?
A film about passion and people's varying abilities to control it. Javier's sexual confidence is extreme and funny. The ladies, Scarlett in particular, blossom in his presence. Rebecca is a tougher nut to crack, but when she does...
(Perhaps, if we're extremely lucky, his next film - Whatever Works - which has just premiered in NYC, will live up to the hilarity of some of his earlier movies. Larry David stars!)

Report as inappropriate
Amanda said...

Posted on Mar 05 2009 17:41 It really annoys me when people criticize a film because it centers on people, rather than say the bangs and blow ups that they'vegrown used to because of being bombarded by the recent trendsof Hollywood. Woody Allen is a director notorious for making films that focus on the characters- therefore, the diologue and story are central. So, you don't go to a Woody Allen film if your attention span is that short that you can't remain seated for longer than five minutes in order to give the film a chance and allow for you to become familiar with the characters, It's like life, you have to be patient if you want to understand the nature of people! It is for this reason that I find Woody Allen film's so interesting and refreshing- for, they center on another way of life and give us an insight into alternative perspectives! It's definately refreshing in comparison to your average Hollywood blockbuster.

Report as inappropriate
Paula Moreira said...

Posted on Mar 01 2009 22:36 The most sensual, interesting, personal, eccentric movie of the year. Woody Allen is an absolute genius, the script is so realistic and vibrant and each character delivered an amazing performance throughout the whole movie. It would be a huge mistake not to watch it! A work of art!

Report as inappropriate
SteveH said...

Posted on Mar 01 2009 10:17 This felt a bit like Sex and the City does Barthelonya, but without the sex, as the leading characters trough their way through tapas and red wine at a variety of art shows, guitar recitals, and architectural tours. The leading man is your typical bohemian Spanish artist, but with you know a private plane, vintage alfa romeo, and last year's Burberry collection for bohemian artists; you get the picture. Of the female cast, Rebecca Hall excels as the serious one, and Scarlett Johansen does an ok job as the flighty one, how Penelope Cruz got an oscar for the mad Spanish bint is beyond me, maybe for language skills ? Anyway, I don't think this was as bad as many reviewers suggest, it's well crafted and good entertainment so long as you don't expect more than a romcom...oh btw it isn't funny though.

Report as inappropriate
Ed said...

Posted on Feb 28 2009 18:53 Possibly the longest hour of my life, and the first time I've walked out of a film. To simltaneously produce the most irritating and yet most tedious hour of cinema I've ever sat through is really quite some achievement.

Report as inappropriate
Miss Tab said...

Posted on Feb 27 2009 08:28 Sadly, I wasn't impressed, it didn't really go anywhere, and when it ended I didn't feel like it had really ever started. Bit of a poor show. If you have to see it, wait for the DVD.

Report as inappropriate
Cristina said...

Posted on Feb 23 2009 16:33 Well I adored it... Frivolous and sexy, and Cruz in particular was superb.
Also Woody Allen is wonderful, and this film is refreshing and youthful and fun. Go see.

Report as inappropriate
Marla said...

Posted on Feb 23 2009 16:28 Huh..
Well I really liked this film.
I thought Cruz was superb and Johannson was good.
It's a sexy film.

Report as inappropriate
Paul said...

Posted on Feb 22 2009 10:36 very poor film i didnt see penelope cruz as we walked out after 50 mins why? it was boring . . it wasnt a low budget film thats an insult to low budget films..but woody allen so bad ..what was he trying to achieve lost me very poorly directed . . . following a hen party in barcelona would have been low budget and more interesting and thats without a director . . . sorry woody but did you watch your own film . . . omg this has a bafta award and an oscar nomination . . . thats very misleading . . . . dont waste your money dont go!!! . . . paul

Report as inappropriate
Lucy said...

Posted on Feb 19 2009 19:00 I'm glad to hear that even the guys thought this was a dreadful film, Woody is consistantly over-valued and this is yet another example of a film based purely on his own fantasies. Absolute crap!

Report as inappropriate
ayesha said...

Posted on Feb 19 2009 15:27 watching it the narrator voice was not relovent i started watching it and thought it was a low budget film but when penelope cruz came in i started wondering what the hell are they thinking and how much for the film to cost
i think it was a average film and the actors and actresses must of worked very hard (not including scarkett johanson) next film shes in i shall not be attending

Report as inappropriate