A very cute short film, with some hilarious segments (as mentioned by the main reviewer). The ending was quite surprising (I had not heard what it was, before I saw it), and very funny. I can understand why audiences of the time gave it the most enthusiastic laughter of Buster's films.
Time Out saysKeaton's favourite, apparently, of his early shorts - perhaps because it's essentially plot-free, allowing Buster to concentrate on his comic routines unimpeded by storytelling considerations. It begins with a flurry of suicide gags in which the down and out hero tries unsuccessfully to do himself in. Next comes a beautifully orchestrated number involving the rolling of a cigarette and the landing of a series of increasingly large fish. There's a leisurely passage exploring all the humorous ways of climbing aboard a horse and, for the grand finale, a fast-paced knockabout in which Buster vanquishes a bunch of villains who have wandered into the picture. Rough-edged, but all the familiar virtues - inventiveness, timing, athletic grace and an underlying melancholy - are present in a state of vigorous germination.