Is Guillermo del Toro the right man to direct 'The Hobbit'?
Time Out wonders if the 'Pan's Labyrinth' director can do Tolkien's work justice.
Del Toro will be moving to New Zealand for the next four years to focus all his energies on the project, working in tandem with Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh and the WETA team to bring the films to fruition, and though there are no details on casting or script as yet, it is assumed that Ian McKellen will be returning to the role of the ageless Gandalf.
All we know about the films themselves is that one of them will be a straight adaptation of 'The Hobbit', while the other will span the 60–year period between that story and its epic successor.
Tolkienites worldwide will be rubbing their hairy hands together at this news, but is del Toro really the right director for the job?
On the surface, there seems to be no one better: often touted as Mexico's answer to Peter Jackson, the two share a love of deep fantasy with a focus on character and narrative consequence rare in films of that genre. They both started out on small-scale, low-budget horror projects before upping stumps to Hollywood (with varying degrees of success), but both have kept one foot firmly rooted in the soil of their homeland. Both have brought an unprecedented level of darkness and emotional intensity to the fantasy genre, and both are deeply beloved of the online fanboy community.
But the fact remains that del Toro has never handled a project on this scale before.
His previous big-budget studio experiments – 'Hellboy' and 'Blade 2' – were entertaining but fairly unsuccesful, unable to marry the director's ambitious comic-book storylines with the logistics of mainstream storytelling (though advance word on 'Hellboy 2' is extremely positive). Del Toro's more succesful forays into the fantasy genre – Spanish language efforts 'The Devil's Backbone' and 'Pan's Labyrinth' – were both notably smaller projects, confined to one location, weaving a claustrophobic fairytale atmosphere rather than the grand heroics required for a Tolkien adaptation.
And what will these adaptations entail? 'The Hobbit' itself is a fairly straightforward road narrative, though it's likely Jackson will push to widen the scope, taking in such off-page action as Gandalf's battle with 'The Necromancer', and Sauron's ensuing flight to Mordor. As a consequence, less important material is likely to be cut: the Norse-inspired passage with the mysterious bear-man seems likely to go.
The other problem with 'The Hobbit' in relation to Jackson's envisioning of the 'Rings' universe is its relative innocence: there are a lot of japes, pratfalls and daft musical interludes, the whole affair possessing a much lighter, more comic tone than its sequel: appropriate for a book which began life as a series of stories told aloud to Tolkien's children.
And what of this mysterious second film? Tolkien left innumerable notes, sketches and unfinished stories spanning the period, but there are still going to be a lot of blanks to fill in, and, as the later stages of the 'Rings' trilogy proved, Peter Jackson is a man willing to let his imagination run away with him, sometimes a little too far: no doubt we'll be treated to a fair amount of winsome Enya-scored elvish love scenes. But there's also scope for some fairly gripping stuff: Gollum's travels will no doubt play a large part, as will the corruption of Saruman (though it remains to be seen whether Christopher Lee will return, given his hissy fit over the excision of his death scene from the theatrical cut of 'Return of the King').
The eyes (and webcams) of the world will be on this project for the next four years, with expectation running higher than for any other film in history. But if del Toro can succesfully widen his scope and work fruitfully with the talented WETA team; if Jackson and his scriptwriters can find a convincing through-narrative for both films and reign in a tendency towards self indulgence; if everyone can remember this is just a movie... then we may be looking at something truly special.
Author: Tom Huddleston
Director Tom Hooper and his cast tell us how they turned the super-musical into movie blockbuster.
The Time Out film team weighs in on the nominees for the 2013 Academy Awards
Get ready for the big guns… Spielberg, Tarantino and Bigelow
Daniel Craig’s 007 comeback, a genius indie romcom and all the mysteries behind ‘The Shining’ unravelled.
The results of our study on the state of films and filmgoing in 2012.
Read 'Time Out film debate 2012 highlights'
'The Hobbit' actor tells us why he wouldn't have a pint with Bilbo Baggins.
Dave Calhoun speaks to the director of 'Skyfall' about the latest film in the Bond franchise.
The genre-hopping director tells us how he invented a new genre with 'Life of Pi'
The twice Palme d'Or-winning director discusses 'Amour'.
Read our interview with Michael Haneke
The Danish director talks about his powerful new drama 'The Hunt'.
Read our interview with Thomas Vinterberg'
Time Out looks back at the impact of the 'Twilight' saga.
Discover what 'Twilight' has done for us
Time Out heads to the Lake District to visit director Ben Wheatley on set.
Read about our visit to the 'Sightseers' set
The director talks about 'Frankenweenie', which he describes as 'the ultimate memory piece'.
Read our interview with Tim burton
Our pick of the best films showing over the festive period.
Read 'The top ten Christmas films of 2012'
Mean Girls? Dirty Dancing? Tell us your favourite film guilty pleasure.
Read 'Film guilty pleasures'
What will Disney do to 'Star Wars'?
Read about the new 'Star Wars' trilogy
Ten young actors come of age on the silver screen.
Read 'When teen stars turn serious'
From Connery to Craig, we revisit all 22 Bond films.
Read '50 years of James Bond'
The director talks Scientology and working with Joaquin Phoenix.
Read the interview
Ten funny horror movies which went spectacularly off the rails.
Read 'Hilarious horror films'
The director talks psychopaths and theatre – 'my least favourite artform'.
Read the interview
We round-up the five best horror movies of Autumn 2012.
Read about this Autumn's best horror movies
Time Out visits Istanbul to see the latest Bond movie being made.
Read 'On the set of Skyfall'
Does Skyfall refresh or rehash the James Bond franchise?
The British director explains why 'Ginger and Rosa' is her most mainstream film yet.
'I’m almost as in demand as Brad Pitt’