Jay Z – 'Magna Carta Holy Grail' album review

Is Mr Beyoncé's new album the holy grail or an unholy fail...?



Add +

Time Out Ratings

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

Anything Ye can do, Jay can do better. Whereas Kanye West merely promoted his recent album, ‘Yeezus’ by crediting God with a guest appearance and claiming divine status, Mr Z’s installed his artwork in Salisbury Cathedral, alongside one of the last four original copies of the Magna Carta. He’s flipped a middle finger to the charts, taking $5million from Samsung to leak his own album via an app whose downloads won’t count to its Top 40 position. And yeah... he’s claiming divine status too.

So is ‘Magna Carta Holy Grail’ a piece of transcendental musical brilliance? Erm, not really. Of the 14 tracks (bulked out by two 50-second musical interludes), a couple are excellent, seven are decent, four are yawny in the extreme and one sounds like it was rescued from the studio bin while they were creating the ‘Great Gatsby’ soundtrack.

No faulting the production, though. ‘La Familia’ is awash with shimmering, off-kilter computerised textures that could be J Dilla soundtracking a Megadrive game. ‘Heaven’ – alongside a number of this album’s highlights – sounds like a futuristic update of the Wu-Tang's ‘36 Chambers’ beat, with a scratchy oriental loop overlaying jerky percussion. ‘Part II (On The Run)’ is enveloped by ringing piano chords and layer upon layer of Beyoncé’s  silky, multi-tracked voice.‘F.U.T.W.’ unleashes a galumphing bassline upon a music-box melody, organ stabs and a wash of flange-heavy brass. And in the track’s final verse, Jay suddenly hits his vocal flow: his rhymes lock into a tight, funky groove and for one glorious moment, he’s riding the beat for all its worth, once again spitting like the MC who created ‘Reasonable Doubt’.

But it’s a moment that’s notable by the absence of similar fare. ‘Tom Ford’ is a bloopy 8-bit dirge whose conceit seems to involve Hova repeating the designer's name as often as possible. ‘Somewhere In America’ features a curious Miley Cyrus-baiting outro where he spends a full 45 seconds yelling ‘Twerk, Miley, twerk!’. At one point he attempts to chalk Cassius Clay’s Parkinson’s up to a government conspiracy. And on the acoustica-strafed, string-laden paean to fatherhood that is ‘Jay Z Blue’ we get the snigger-inducing rhyme of: ‘Baby need Pampers/Daddy need at least three weeks in the Hamptons’.

Essentially, it’s business as usual: another competent effort from a once-stunning MC who hasn’t produced anything breathtaking since midway through last century. It’s not bad. It’s not great. But one thing’s for sure: Gods don’t make music like they used to.

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Watch Jay Z's 'Magna Carta Holy Grail' album trailer

See Jay-Z live in London

Jay Brannan

Baby-faced singer-songwriter Brannan, who bared all in the indie film 'Shortbus', brings his cutesy, Brooklyn-style acoustic rhymes to town.

  1. Jazz Cafe Parkway, Camden, NW1 7PG
  2. Fri Oct 17
Buy tickets
See all Jay Z gigs

Users say


See Jay Z live in London

Jay Brannan

Baby-faced singer-songwriter Brannan, who bared all in the indie film 'Shortbus', brings his cutesy, Brooklyn-style acoustic rhymes to town.

  1. Jazz Cafe Parkway, Camden, NW1 7PG
  2. Fri Oct 17
Buy tickets

The O'Jays

Get on the Love Train – or rather the Jubilee Line – to catch the soul survivors as they play their first London shows in over two decades. The gigs are part of their current world tour, celebrating 50 years in the business, and they've still got two original members who know exactly how to Give the People What They Want.

  1. Indigo2 Millennium Way, Greenwich, SE10 0DX
  2. Thu Sep 18 - Fri Sep 19
Buy tickets

John Legend

  • Critics choice

R&B crooner John Legend tackles the genre with classy, old-school charm, gently escorting listeners from candlelit dinners to steamy dance floors and, finally, to silk-adorned bedrooms. A church choir leader, pianist, songwriter and arranger, Legend worked behind the scenes with the likes of Jay-Z, Kanye West, Nas, Mary J Blige, Alicia Keys and even Michael Jackson, and now he's a star in his own right. (Kanye returned the favour with production duties on Legend's latest album 'Love in the Future'.)

  1. Eventim Apollo Hammersmith 45 Queen Caroline St, W6 9QH
  2. Mon Oct 13 - Thu Oct 16
Buy tickets

Listen to 'Magna Carta Holy Grail' on Spotify

Read more music features

Interview: La Roux

‘Where’s the fucking melody?’ Elly Jackson sets us right about songcraft, splits and the solitary life

Interview: Burt Bacharach

The 86-year-old songwriting legend reveals the secrets of his youthful vigour: lightweight sneakers and clean teeth, apparently

What's the deal with… Rixton

These Twitter heart throbs topped the chart at the weekend – here's what you should know

Interview: Dead Rat Orchestra

Meet the London band who are getting ready to tour the UK by canal boat

See all Time Out music features