Peggy Sue – 'Choir of Echoes' album review

On an album about voices, the folk-pop trio ditch twee and find a sound that's distinctly their own



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>4/5

Peggy Sue have a thing about voices. The Brighton trio describe their fourth LP, ‘Choir of Echoes’, as ‘an album about singing. About losing your voice and finding it again. Voices keeping each other company and voices competing for space… Choruses. Duets. Whispers and shouts.’ As wistful and airy-fairy as this all sounds, it makes a spot-on kind of sense as the 13 songs on ‘Choir of Echoes’ unfold.

Peggy Sue’s two vocalists, Rosa Slade and Katy Young, have always made their impeccable harmonies central to the band’s identity. Since the group’s early days, when they were called Peggy Sue And The Pirates and supported Mumford & Sons, Slade and Young have displayed a deft ability to marry their voices in a unique way that allows each to shine and both to blend. What they have chosen to sacrifice along the way are any of the lingering hints of twee that came with their old seafaring suffix.

Often losing out in comparisons to label-mates First Aid Kit, Peggy Sue have come closest to carving out their own niche on this fourth attempt, by adding some sour to the sweet. The folkiest number on ‘Choir of Echoes’, ‘How Heavy the Quiet Between Your Mouth and Mine’, offers up sweet vocals that bely the dark place where the lyrics go: ‘We filled it with words in the hope that we could drown it out / But it was too loud.’. The group’s stint touring with Jack White can be heard in the blues-influenced first single, ‘Idle’, with its mantra-like opening – ‘Let the devil make work for my idle hands’ – which wouldn’t sound out of place bellowed by a gospel choir.

Elsewhere on the album, both the sound and sentiment are deliciously dark and distinct. ‘Longest Day of the Year Blues’ revels in misery, filled with wonderfully forlorn ‘oooh’s and ‘aaah’s, and on closing track ‘The Error Of Your Ways’, rumbling drums rugby-tackle the singers’ dulcet tones. An album obsessed with voices may prove to be the turning point where Peggy Sue found their very own.

Buy this album here

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Listen to Peggy Sue on Spotify

Watch the video for 'Idle'

Users say


Read more music features

The 10 best Courtney Barnett lyrics

We pick the best lines written so far by the great young Australian singer-songwriter

Giorgio Moroder and Nile Rodgers: Time Out meets the hit makers

Between them, the two founding fathers of disco have a combined age of 136 and dozens of era-defining hits. Now they’re each releasing their first new album in decades

Five things you didn’t know about Matthew E White

The super-cool US singer-songwriter tells us about touring, Glastonbury and ‘Fresh Blood’

The best of the London grime scene

Kanye who? Yeezy’s been clamouring to work with London’s finest grime MCs – catch them while you can

Caribou picks his top tracks from ‘The Longest Mixtape’

We asked Dan Snaith for five favourites from his epic, 1,000-song playlist

See all Time Out music features