• Time Out Chicago
    • Time Out Worldwide
    • Travel
    • Book store
    • Subscribe to Time Out New York
    • Subscriber Services
  • Time Out New York
  • Ad Space
    (728 x 90)
  • Search
  •  
    • Home
    • Apartments
    • Art
    • Books
    • Clubs
    • Comedy
    • Dance
    • Film
    • Games
    • Gay
    • I, New York
    • Kids
    • Museums & Culture
    • Music
    • Opera & Classical
    • Restaurants & Bars
    • Sex & Dating
    • Shopping
    • Spas & Sport
    • Theater
    • Travel
    • TV & DVD
  • « BACK TO SEARCH
    • In this series

      • Articles
        • Opinions are like…

        • Master raters

        • Five-course squeal

        • Booty haul

        • Bias beware

        • TONY's bookmarks

        • Who has the best criticism?

        • Petty criticisms

        • Win our swag!

        • Best of TONY reviews, 2007

        • Introduction: The critical condition

        • Probing question: What's in store for criticism?

        • Probing question: What makes a critic a critic?

        • Probing question: What's the impact of citizen reviews?

        • Probing question: How do you make your voice heard?

        • Probing question: Should young writers aspire to be critics?

        • Probing question: Will critics matter in 2020?

        • Post Its


    • Tools

      • E-mail

        E-mail a friend





        • * Mandatory

        • View our privacy policy
      • Print
      • Rate & comment
        [X]

        • (will not appear on site)
          *Required
          •  characters left

        • View our privacy policy
      • Report an error

        Report an error


        • View our privacy policy
      • Share this
        • Delicious
        • Digg
        • Facebook
        • reddit
        • StumbleUpon


  • Blogs

    The TONY Blog

    • 1 Thing: Weekend

    • Published on 7/25/08

    • Here’s the "1 Thing" to do this weekend if you feel...

    More posts »





    The Feed

    • Ask The Feed: One night not in Memphis

    • Published on 7/24/08

    • Dear Anne-Marie...

    More posts »





    Video

    Tons of clips!

    • Get a heads-up on the week's biggest events, go inside the hottest restaurants, trendiest shops, and more.

    Watch videos »





  • Ad Space
    (120 x 240)


  • TONY Free Flix

    • Get free tickets to hot new movie releases.





    Prizes & Promotions

    • Win prizes and get discounts, event invites and more.





    TONY Nightlife+

    • Get real-time information for bars, clubs and restaurants on your mobile.





    TONY on the radio

    • Tune in to Out There with TONY on WPS1.org for conversations with our
      editors and special guests.





    Subscribe

    • • Subscribe now

    • • Give a gift

    • • Subscriber services





  • Features

    Time Out New York / Issue 636 : Dec 6–12, 2007
    Bloggers vs critics

    Probing question: Should young writers aspire to be critics?

    So if I’m 18 years old, call you and tell you I want to be a critic, what advice do you give? Go for it? Don’t?

    Mario Naves
    Get a day job.

    Charlie Finch
    Get an agent.

    Douglas Wolk, critic, author, Reading Comics; blogger, Lacunae
    Don’t do it!!

    Dwight Garner, critic, The New York Times and Paper Cuts blog
    Read everything you can get your hands on, great literature and also great criticism—Pauline Kael, Dwight Macdonald, George Orwell, James Agee, John Updike, Alfred Kazin, H.L. Mencken, etc. Read the current critics, too—become the kind of person who flips to the “back of the book” (a.k.a. the reviews) first in all kinds of magazines and newspapers. Remember what criticism is: the art of making fine distinctions. Start writing for your school newspaper, high school or college—I bet it doesn’t have a book critic. Yet.

    Andy Horwitz
    Start seeing as much work as you possibly can, always read the program notes, do your research and write, write, write.

    Adam Buckman
    Stay the hell away from the Post, because I plan on clinging to this job until my remote-control has to be pried from my cold, dead hands.

    Next: Will critics matter in 2020? »




    • Comments
    • |
    • Leave a comment
    [X]

    • (will not appear on site)
      *Required
      •  characters left

    • View our privacy policy

    • No comments yet. Click here and be the first!



      • Subscribe now and save 90%!

      • Time Out Covers
        • • One year of Time Out New York for $19.97
        • • Special issues and guides throughout the year include: Cheap Eats, the Spa issue, Summer Concert Preview, Fall Preview and the Holiday Gift Guide.
        • • Day-by-day listings for the events, clubs, artists and restaurant openings in every borough of the city that you won't want to miss!

      • Time Out New York respects your privacy. We will only use your e-mail address in order to contact you regarding to your subscription and to send you our weekly e-newsletter. We will not share this information with anyone.

  • Ad Space
    (320 x 110)


    Ad Space
    (300 x 250)


  • Most viewed in Features

    • Articles
    • Top 5 ways to be an Internet success
    • What's your fantasy
    • Your perfect bar
    • Naked poll (men)
    • Culture report
    • We're still horny
    • Eat Out Awards 2008
    • What the guidebooks won’t tell you
    • Why the hipster must die
    • Chill-out bars


  • Ad Space
    (160 x 600)


    Ad Space
    (160 x 600)
    • Copyright © 2000–2008 Time Out New York
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact Us
    • Media Kit & Advertising
    • Get Listed
    • We're Hiring
    • Subscribe
    • Subscriber Services
    • Site Map
    • Home
    • Apartments
    • Art
    • Books
    • Clubs
    • Comedy
    • Dance
    • Film
    • Games
    • Gay & Lesbian
    • I, New York
    • Kids
    • Museums & Culture
    • Music
    • Opera & Classical
    • Restaurants & Bars
    • Sex & Dating
    • Shopping
    • Spas & Sport
    • Theater
    • Travel
    • TV & DVD
    • Visit our sister sites:
    • Time Out New York Kids
    • Time Out Chicago
    • Time Out London
    • Time Out Worldwide