Heir to the Throne: Crowning NYC's Best Burger

0

Comments

Add +

Want to try the best burger? Think another patty should have taken the prize? Let us know on Twitter with the #BestBurgerNYC hashtag.


Official rules


Users say

150 comments
Joe
Joe

this is great

Myrna
Myrna

I became a fan of the Burger Bistro after I had their "Elvis" burger which turned out a scary, intriguing yet totally orgasmic experience!!!

Julie
Julie

The Burger Bistro is hands down the best burger in NY state! I travel from Westchester for a burger, it's worth every minute. Plus, the owner John is a sexy beast!

joe
joe

EATS IS WHERE IT IS!!!!!!!!!!

Kerry
Kerry

These lists are always subjective and, usually intentionally, invite debate. And these lists SHOULD be and do exactly those things. I believe the subjectivity comes from something not usually discussed, and it is the TYPE of burger one prefers. People who crave Corner Bistro or The Burger Joint prefer more simple, almost nostalgic beef patty sandwiches, and are averse to the grandiosity of an even pedestrian 5 Napkins or Spotted Pig burger, nor the vaulted pedigree of the Black Label at Minetta. Next year dozens of food sites and periodicals will ask the same question to the same very large majority who have yet to try—or will ever get a chance to try—the options up for voting this year. So i won't vote, but appreciate that almost every month, without even looking for one, I'll be made aware of another 5 or 10 new burgers that I "must try" or become "iconic" after just 3 years. And just to prove that I'm not here to pretend I'm above a good, fun competition, you can check out my OWN list of—not TOP or BEST—my FAVORITE Gotham burgers here... http://PHUDE-nyc.com/phude-for-thought/2012-2/phude-nycs-top-10-favorite-nyc-burgers-so-far/ ...broken down by categories such as Classic Diner-Style, Retro Burger, Pub Burger, and more. (You'll discover that I definitely have a 'type"...!) KACnyc

Robert
Robert

NY BEER COMPANY all the way! Great music, great draft selection, awesome food, awesome Chef! 5 Stars! a must see!

Franca
Franca

I agree....Burger Bistro all the way! And aside from the delicious food, the atmosphere and service never disapoint...

Bill W.
Bill W.

Are you all kidding me!!! BURGER BISTRO by far has the best burger in the city!!! Anyone who knows good food know this. PERIOD!!!

Popcorn Love
Popcorn Love

The place to be for yummy burgers! Veggie burger is delish! PoP!

Johnny Jimenez
Johnny Jimenez

Bonnies Grill in park slope Brooklyn is the best burger joint in new york hands down! You have your choice of all the free toppings like lettuce, tomato, onion, pickle, or jalapenos then if you like you can add mushrooms, bacon,avocado,caramelized onion ohh man!!!! I get a burger from here at least twice a week. Plus they have the best wings in New york as well

Michael
Michael

Kettle black in bay ridge Brooklyn has the sickest burgers in NY. The kettle black in bay ridge Brooklyn. The services is off the hook as well. When ever I'm there they is always packed but the bar tenders ever forget who you are. I hate when I go out to these other bars and the buy back are few an far apart. Not at the kettle, those bartenders are always on their game. P.s. the wings are no joke as well!!!!! I wanted to give it more stars for the ratings but it won't let me.

carlos
carlos

NYC beer company. Fantastic burger. Great sound. We loved it.

Lisa
Lisa

Best burger !!

Katie lorincz
Katie lorincz

The kettle black in bay ridge Brooklyn serve the best burgers In town. Their wings are award winning as well and the staff and service is excellent. The atmosphere is extremely welcoming and friendly I hope the kettle black wins because in my mind the have the best burgers , wings ,salads and more in the city.

Matthew king
Matthew king

Kettle black bay ridge Brooklyn best burgers , wings and all around decor in the city

Billy
Billy

I make this review special by revealing that I am a vegetarian, unless I’m at EATS on lex. Oh y es, I’m acutely aware that the cow that I’m eating likely had a horrible life and I understand that my gastrointestinal tract will object the following day in an unpleasant manner. But…you w ould understand if you had one! It's the best. burger. in. town. Trust me!

Billy
Billy

I make this review special by revealing that I am a vegetarian, unless I’m at EATS on lex. Oh yes, I’m acutely aware that the cow that I’m eating likely had a horrible life and I understand that my gastrointestinal tract will object the following day in an unpleasant manner. But…you would understand if you had one! It's the best. burger. in. town. Trust me!

Chad
Chad

WilliamsBurger rocks! Great music great food great burger great name should I keep going

Reza
Reza

Best hands down Burger and Nets game when I m in town.

cliff smith
cliff smith

Eats best burger .you need good food stop by.

 Russell
Russell

WilliamsBurger hands down has the best burgers around. People from far come to eat here!!!! Come and try us out you'll end up coming back again and again...

Tracey Glover
Tracey Glover

New York Beer Company best burger in the city by a country mile .... YUM,

Paulie
Paulie

NEW YORK BEER COMPANY has the best burger and beer in NYC!!! BEST BURGER CHAMPION HANDS DOWN!!!!

Danielle
Danielle

Kettle block all the way for everything.. Best burgers, wings, and beer!

Oppy
Oppy

Mason jar best burger in NYC!

miguel pulla
miguel pulla

the burger bistro is the best place to eat at good and great burger

Lauren
Lauren

Had a delicious burger at the Burger Bistro before I was vegetarian, and was more than pleasantly surprised with the veggie version after the switch. They don't disappoint!

Donna
Donna

Burger Bistro the Best as seen on TV!

Diane
Diane

KETTLE BLACK - all the way!

Bridget
Bridget

Kettle Black is the BEST !!!!!!!!!!

Monica
Monica

WilliamsBurger by miles and miles . Name is also genus too

Christy
Christy

Love the burgers. Dress them up , dress them down. The Kettle Black deserves the crown

Joseph
Joseph

Dont settle The best burger is at the Kettle. Not only the best burgers but the best wings.

Paul
Paul

NY BEER COMPANY! HANDS DOWN THE BEST IN NYC!!

Brian
Brian

Piper's Kilt is the best from the Bronx

Harolin
Harolin

Piper's kilt not only have the best burgers from the Bronx, but the most amazing hot wings... the sauce is AMAZING

Marcel carolina
Marcel carolina

Well, I am from the bronx so I have to say Piper's Kilt. Delicious!!

Yizza
Yizza

That's easy, Piper's Kilt @ Bronx

Amelia
Amelia

The tastiest burger is from Piper's Kilt. Best place from the Bronx

BRIANNA
BRIANNA

People, you must go to Piper's Kilt at the Bronx, You won't regret it

Chris Z
Chris Z

Without a doubt Bonnie's grill. And while you are at it you should get yourself some wings and a bottle of Brooklyn Local #2 for the full experience.

Mendoza
Mendoza

Bonnie's. C'mon, is there a doubt?

Henrietta
Henrietta

Bonnie's Grill in Park Slope. Always the fave with all the fixin's