Best new calzones in NYC: Fresh takes on the Italian turnover

Popping up at pizza hipster haunts like Roberta’s and new slice joints like Tufino, calzones are having a moment. Here are NYC’s best new calzones.

0

Comments

Add +

In recent years, pizza has gotten plenty of au courant twists, with offbeat toppings, local ingredients and deep-fried modernizations dominating the scene, but calzones have largely been neglected in the pie case. Now, a few ballsy pizzerias—including Roberta’s, Motorino and Brooklyn Central—are defying the tired cheese-sauce-dough norm, slinging updated versions of the Italian fold-over into their wood-fired ovens. These ain’t your nonna’s calzones.


  • Photograph: Melissa Sinclair

    Involto at Roberta's

    The Bushwick pizza phenom has been slinging stellar pies since 2008, but it added this not-so-classic fold-over to the menu only last year. The love child of a calzone and a stromboli, this hefty, dough-swaddled specialty is built with the same provisions that make the pizzeria’s artisanal rounds destination-worthy. The wonderfully charred crust is folded up like a brick-oven burrito, with a cleft on top, bubbling the three cheeses (fluffy Narragansett Creamery ricotta, melty house-made mozzarella and nutty Parmigiano) and crisping the edges of the peppercorn-studded sopressata hidden underneath. Roasted red peppers and sweet tomatoes mellow the salami’s spice, finished with a subtle backbeat of homegrown basil and oregano. 261 Moore St between Bogart and White Sts, Bushwick, Brooklyn (718-417-1118, robertaspizza.com). $16.

  • Photograph: Filip Wolak

    Porchetta calzone at Motorino

    At his Williamsburg location—
which opened last June—Mathieu Palombino’s swine-filled football is an all-out carnivore indulgence. Bolstered by prosciutto di Parma slices, the meaty mess highlights luscious porchetta, a stuffed-and-rolled 12-hour pork roast teeming with garlic, sage, rosemary and thyme. Like an Italian-accented ham-and-cheese, gooey stretches of provolone picante and pecorino romano are pinched between 
folds of the pizzeria’s famed crust. Parsley sprigs and a drizzle of olive oil freshen things up, while a 
side of snappy marinara has nice acidity to counter the fatty meat. 
139 Broadway between Bedford and Driggs Aves, Williamsburg, Brooklyn (718-599-8899, motorinopizza
.com). $18.

  • Photograph: Jennifer Arnow

    Fritto calzone at Tufino Pizzeria Napoletana

    At Stephen Menna’s Astoria pizza parlor, which opened last December, the fried calzone is more than a novelty—it’s a puffed-up wonder, a hybrid of street-fair zeppole and red-sauce slice. Oozing crazy-rich ricotta, fior di latte mozzarella, salty prosciutto cotto and an enlivening kick of black pepper, the stuffed-to-the-brim turnover takes a dip in the fryer for a golden, crackling hull. Menna—a Paulie Gee’s alum—spoons robust, tangy tomato sauce on top before giving the pouch a blast in the wood-fired Stefano Ferrara oven. 36-08 Ditmars Blvd between 36th and 37th Sts, Astoria, Queens (718-278-4800, tufinopizzeria.com). $12.

  • Photograph: Michael Rudin

    S'mores calzone at Brooklyn Central

    At his Park Slope pizzeria, launched last October, owner-pizzaiolo Matt Hyland (Sottocasa) swaps the standard marinara-and-mozz calzone filling for classic campfire accoutrements: chocolate, marshmallow and graham crackers. Sticky pulls of melted mallow and ribbons of cocoa-hazelnut Nutella overlap inside a pillowy, crisp pizza-dough pod, cooked to a char-spotted smolder inside a tiled Ferrara inferno. With all of the familiarity of the bonfire favorite, the sweet meal-ender is finished with a generous dusting of fine graham-cracker crumbs. 289 Fifth Ave between 1st and 2nd Sts, Park Slope, Brooklyn (347-725-4891, brooklyncentralpizza.com). $8.

  • Photograph: Hannah Mattix

    Calzone Fritto at Don Antonio by Starita

    There’s no marinara or mozzarella to be found in the massive, golden-fried pocket at this midtown Neapolitan joint, opened last year by Roberto Caporuscio (Kesté Pizza & Vino) and his mentor, Antonio Starita (owner of Naples’ renowned Pizzeria Starita a Materdei). Instead, this green variety bundles silky escarole—braised down to a bitter wilt—with briny anchovies, plump raisins, toasted pine nuts and salty cured Gaeta olives. The earthy pitch of the filling is matched by the sour, yeasty tang of the fried-then-baked shell, made with imported Caputo “OO” flour and poufed up in the 900-degree oven. 309 W 50th St between Eighth and Ninth Aves (646-719-1043, donantoniopizza.com). $17.

Photograph: Melissa Sinclair

Involto at Roberta's

The Bushwick pizza phenom has been slinging stellar pies since 2008, but it added this not-so-classic fold-over to the menu only last year. The love child of a calzone and a stromboli, this hefty, dough-swaddled specialty is built with the same provisions that make the pizzeria’s artisanal rounds destination-worthy. The wonderfully charred crust is folded up like a brick-oven burrito, with a cleft on top, bubbling the three cheeses (fluffy Narragansett Creamery ricotta, melty house-made mozzarella and nutty Parmigiano) and crisping the edges of the peppercorn-studded sopressata hidden underneath. Roasted red peppers and sweet tomatoes mellow the salami’s spice, finished with a subtle backbeat of homegrown basil and oregano. 261 Moore St between Bogart and White Sts, Bushwick, Brooklyn (718-417-1118, robertaspizza.com). $16.


Users say

0 comments

Food & Drink events calendar

  1. Smorgasburg

    The venerable epicurean extravaganza returns the w...

Time Out videos



Tweets by Time Out NY

Subscribe to Time Out New York on Spotify for playlists and recommendations from our Music team.

Check out New York's best restaurants, hottest street style, cool apartments and more.