Pie flavors in NYC

pieslideshow1

NYC pies by type

candybar09MOMOFUKU

Candy Bar at Momofuku Bakery & Milk Bar 207 Second Ave between 12th and 13th Sts  * 15 W 56th St between Fifth and Sixth Aves * 382 Metropolitan Ave between Havemeyer and Marcy Aves, Williamsburg, Brooklyn * momofuku.com/milk-bar. Slice $5.25, eight-inch pie $44.

shoofly12FIRSTPRIZE

Shoofly at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

mississippimud_LITTLEPIE

Mississippi Mud at Little Pie Company 424 W 43rd St between Ninth and Tenth Aves (212-736-4780, littlepiecompany.com). Slice $4, five-inch pie $7.50, eight-inch pie $22, ten-inch pie $30.

crackpie08MOMOFUKU

Crack Pie at Momofuku Bakery & Milk Bar 207 Second Ave between 12th and 13th Sts  * 15 W 56th St between Fifth and Sixth Aves * 382 Metropolitan Ave between Havemeyer and Marcy Aves, Williamsburg, Brooklyn * momofuku.com/milk-bar. Slice $5.25, eight-inch pie $44.

cocnutcreamBILLYS

Coconut cream at Billy's Bakery 184 Ninth Ave between 21st and 22nd Sts (212-647-9956, billysbakerynyc.com) * 75 Franklin St between Broadway and Church St  (212-647-9958, billysbakerynyc.com). Slice $4.25, nine-inch pie $24.

msourcherry01BUBBYS

Michigan sour cherry at Bubby's 120 Hudson St between Franklin and North Moore Sts (212-219-0666) * 1 Main St between Plymouth and Water Sts, Dumbo, Brooklyn (718-222-0666, bubbys.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $35.

pumpkinpraline07BUBBYS

Pumpkin with organic pecan pralines at Bubby's 120 Hudson St between Franklin and North Moore Sts (212-219-0666,) * 1 Main St between Plymouth and Water Sts, Dumbo, Brooklyn (718-222-0666, bubbys.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $35.

lime01BUTTERCUP

Key lime with gingersnap crust at Buttercup Bakeshop 973 Second Ave between 51st and 52nd Sts (212-350-4144) * 141 W 72nd St between Amsterdam and Columbus Aves (212-787-3800) * buttercupbakeshop.com. Six-inch pie $7, nine-inch pie $16.

blackoat4x20

Black Bottom Oatmeal at Four & Twenty Blackbirds 439 Third Ave at 8th St, Gowanus, Brooklyn (718-499-2917, birdsblack.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $32.

peanutbutter07SUGARSWEET

Peanut butter at Sugar Sweet Sunshine 126 Rivington St between Essex and Norfolk Sts (212-995-1960, sugarsweetsunshine.com). Slice $4, nine-inch pie $25.

veganapppleBABYCAKES

Vegan apple at Babycakes NYC 248 Broome St between Ludlow and Orchard Sts (212-677-5047, babycakesnyc.com). Eight-inch pie $45.

pearcranberry12BUBBYS

Pear cranberry with gingersnap crumble at Sweet Melissa Patisserie 276 Court St between Butler and Douglass Sts, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn (718-855-3410) * 175 Seventh Ave between 1st and 2nd Sts, Park Slope, Brooklyn * (718-788-2700) * sweetmelissapatisserie.com. Slice $5.50, nine-inch pie $34.

rootbeer01FIRSTPRIZE

Root beer cream at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

sourcreamLITTLEPIE

Sour cream apple walnut at Little Pie Company 424 W 43rd St between Ninth and Tenth Aves (212-736-4780, littlepiecompany.com). Slice $4, five-inch pie $7.50, eight-inch pie $22, ten-inch pie $30.

bmpecan07CLINTONSTREET

Maple bourbon pecan at Clinton Street Baking Company 4 Clinton St between E Houston and Stanton Sts (646-602-6263, clintonstreetbaking.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $22.

pumpkin03ONEGIRLCOOKIES

Pumpkin at One Girl Cookies 68 Dean St between Boerum Pl and Smith St, Cobble Hill, Brooklyn (212-675-4996, onegirlcookies.com). Nine-inch pie $25.

applechedderpiesandthighs

Apple cheddar at Pies 'n' Thighs 166 South 4th St at Driggs Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn (347-529-6090, piesnthighs.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $30.

keylime06STEVES

Key lime at Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies 204 Van Dyke St between Conover and Ferris Sts, Red Hook, Brooklyn (718-858-5333, stevesauthentic.com). Eight-inch pie $15, ten-inch pie $25.

chocmeringue18BUBBYS

Chocolate meringue at Bubby's 120 Hudson St between Franklin and North Moore Sts (212-219-0666) * 1 Main St between Plymouth and Water Sts, Dumbo, Brooklyn (718-222-0666, bubbys.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $35.

buttermilk09IVY

Buttermilk at Ivy Bakery 278 87th St between Third Ave and Ridge Blvd, Bay Ridge, Brooklyn (718-833-1626, ivybakery.com). Nine-inch pie $32.

threeberry16LITTLEPIE

Three berry at Little Pie Company 424 W 43rd St between Ninth and Tenth Aves (212-736-4780, littlepiecompany.com). Slice $4, five-inch pie $7.50, eight-inch pie $22, ten-inch pie $30.

Chocpudding08PIESNTHIGHS

Chocolate pudding at Pies 'n' Thighs 166 South 4th St at Driggs Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn (347-529-6090, piesnthighs.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $30.

chocolatepecanpie07BAKED

Chocolate bourbon pecan at Baked 359 Van Brunt St between Dikeman and Wolcott Sts, Red Hook, Brooklyn (718-222-0345, bakednyc.com). Slice $3.50, nine-inch pie $26.

cranberrycherry_SOUTINE

Cranberry cherry at Soutine Bakery 104 W 70th St between Amsterdam and Columbus Aves (212-496-1450, soutine.com). Slice $4, ten-inch pie $25.

pearcranberrySWEETMELISSA16

Pear cranberry with gingersnap crumble at Sweet Melissa Patisserie 276 Court St between Butler and Douglass Sts, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn (718-855-3410) * 175 Seventh Ave between 1st and 2nd Sts, Park Slope, Brooklyn * (718-788-2700) * sweetmelissapatisserie.com. Slice $5.50, nine-inch pie $34.

blueberry05SUGARSWEET

Blueberry at Sugar Sweet Sunshine 126 Rivington St between Essex and Norfolk Sts (212-995-1960, sugarsweetsunshine.com). Slice $4, nine-inch pie $25.

peachraspberry_CAFELALO2

Peach raspberry at Cafe Lalo 201 W 83rd St between Broadway and Amsterdam Ave (212-496-6031, cafelalo.com). Slice $7, ten-inch pie $25.

mince01SOUTINE

Mince at Soutine Bakery 104 W 70th St between Amsterdam and Columbus Aves (212-496-1450, soutine.com). Slice $4, ten-inch pie $25.

bancocream08_CLINTONSTREET

Banana coconut cream at Clinton Street Baking Company 4 Clinton St between E Houston and Stanton Sts (646-602-6263, clintonstreetbaking.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $22.

grapefruit12PIESNTHIGHS

Grapefruit at Pies 'n' Thighs 166 South 4th St at Driggs Ave, Williamsburg, Brooklyn (347-529-6090, piesnthighs.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $30.

maplewalnutIVY

Maple walnut pie at Ivy Bakery 278 87th St between Third Ave and Ridge Blvd, Bay Ridge, Brooklyn (718-833-1626, ivybakery.com). Nine-inch pie $32.

applepearras15_LALO

Apple pear raspberry at Cafe Lalo 201 W 83rd St between Broadway and Amsterdam Ave (212-496-6031, cafelalo.com). Slice $7, ten-inch pie $25.

cinnamonbunMOMOFUKU

Cinnamon Bun at Momofuku Bakery & Milk Bar 207 Second Ave between 12th and 13th Sts  * 15 W 56th St between Fifth and Sixth Aves * 382 Metropolitan Ave between Havemeyer and Marcy Aves, Williamsburg, Brooklyn * momofuku.com/milk-bar. Slice $5.25, eight-inch pie $44.

banoffee20_BUBBYS

Banoffee at Bubby's 120 Hudson St between Franklin and North Moore Sts (212-219-0666) * 1 Main St between Plymouth and Water Sts, Dumbo, Brooklyn (718-222-0666, bubbys.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $35.

ChocolatePBpretzelFIRSTPRIZE

Chocolate--peanut butter--pretzel at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

spicyhotchocFIRSTPRIZE

Spicy hot chocolate at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

4x20blackbirds_chocoalate

Bittersweet chocolate with ruby port, cranberries and roasted nuts at Four & Twenty Blackbirds 439 Third Ave at 8th St, Gowanus, Brooklyn (718-499-2917, birdsblack.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $32.

caramelapple13BUBBYS

Salted-caramel apple at Bubby's 120 Hudson St between Franklin and North Moore Sts (212-219-0666) * 1 Main St between Plymouth and Water Sts, Dumbo, Brooklyn (718-222-0666, bubbys.com). Slice $7, nine-inch pie $35.

tripleberrySWEETMELISSA

Triple berry with cinnamon crumble at Sweet Melissa Patisserie 276 Court St between Butler and Douglass Sts, Carroll Gardens, Brooklyn (718-855-3410) * 175 Seventh Ave between 1st and 2nd Sts, Park Slope, Brooklyn * (718-788-2700) * sweetmelissapatisserie.com. Slice $5.50, nine-inch pie $34.

shakercitrus09FIRSTPRIZE

Shaker citrus at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

peachpand01BUTTERCUP

Peach pandowdy at Buttercup Bakeshop 973 Second Ave between 51st and 52nd Sts (212-350-4144) * 141 W 72nd St between Amsterdam and Columbus Aves (212-787-3800) * buttercupbakeshop.com. Six-inch pie $7, nine-inch pie $16.

saltyhoney174X20BLACKBIRDS

Salty honey at Four & Twenty Blackbirds 439 Third Ave at 8th St, Gowanus, Brooklyn (718-499-2917, birdsblack.com). Slice $4.50, nine-inch pie $32.

MOMOFUKU

Grasshopper at Momofuku Bakery & Milk Bar 207 Second Ave between 12th and 13th Sts  * 15 W 56th St between Fifth and Sixth Aves * 382 Metropolitan Ave between Havemeyer and Marcy Aves, Williamsburg, Brooklyn * momofuku.com/milk-bar. Slice $5.25, eight-inch pie $44.

pearapplecrumb06CAFELALO

Pear apple crumb at Cafe Lalo 201 W 83rd St between Broadway and Amsterdam Ave (212-496-6031, cafelalo.com). Slice $7, ten-inch pie $23.

strawberryrubarbCRUMBSt

Strawberry rhubarb with oat topping at Buttercup Bakeshop 973 Second Ave between 51st and 52nd Sts (212-350-4144) * 141 W 72nd St between Amsterdam and Columbus Aves (212-787-3800) * buttercupbakeshop.com. Six-inch pie $7, nine-inch pie $16.

lemonmeringue_MITCHEL

Lemon meringue at Mitchel London Foods 458 Ninth Ave between 35th and 36th Sts (212-643-1200) * 22A E 65th St between Fifth and Madison Aves (212-737-2850) * mitchellondonfoods.com. Three-inch pie $4, five-inch pie $15, ten-inch pie $30.

smores13FIRSTPRIZE

S'mores at First Prize Pies (646-338-6812, firstprizepies.com). Two four-inch pies or one nine-inch pie $30.

bananacreamBLUESMOKE

Banana cream at Blue Smoke 116 E 27th St between Park and Lexington Aves (212-447-7733, bluesmoke.com). Slice $7.95, ten-inch pie $32.

billionaireHILLCOUNTRY1

Texas Billionaire at Hill Country Chicken 1123 Broadway at 25th St (212-257-6446, hillcountrychicken.com). Slice $5.50, pie cup $3.50, five-inch pie $6.50, eleven-inch pie $43.

browniepuddingCORNERCAFE1

Brownie pudding at Corner Caf and Bakery 1246 Madison Ave between 89th and 90th Sts (212-860-8060) * 1645 Third Ave at 92nd St (no phone) * cornercafe-bakery.com. Slice $4.25, nine-inch pie $28.

chocpb05TROIS1

Peanut butter at Trois Pommes Patisserie 260 Fifth Ave between Carroll St and Garfield Pl, Park Slope, Brooklyn (718-230-3119, troispommespatisserie.com). Slice $5, nine-inch pie $28.

dbcherryHILLCOUNTRY1

Double cherry with streusel topping at Hill Country Chicken 1123 Broadway at 25th St (212-257-6446, hillcountrychicken.com). Slice $5.50, pie cup $3.50, five-inch pie $6.50, eleven-inch pie $43.