New York's tastiest ten

We've stuffed ourselves all year to be able to judge the most delicious mouthfuls in the city. Here they are.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

1. ARTICHOKE PIE AT DI FARA PIZZA


It stands to reason that if pizza is the quintessential New York food, then the best pizza in New York surely must be the city’s No. 1 dish. Domenico DeMarco, a throwback perfectionist working in a hole-in-the-wall joint, painstakingly stretches every single gorgeous blistered pie to order (naturally, the waits are interminable) for his most legendary combo, ladling on the thin veneer of sauce, fresh mozzarella, freshly grated Reggiano, baby artichokes and pot-snipped herbs. 1424 Ave J at 15th St, Midwood, Brooklyn (718-258-1367). Whole pie: $24.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

2. WARM ROASTED-DUCK SALAD AT SRIPRAPHAI


Red peppers, tomatoes, cucumbers and scallions are drenched in a sauce laden with cilantro, lime and peanut that’s hot and sweet and savory all at once. Then you sit back and realize, Whoa—this is just the appetizer! 64-13 39th Ave between 64th and 65th Sts, Woodside, Queens (718-899-9599). $9.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

3. FOIE GRAS BRÛLÉE AT JEAN GEORGES


Molten custardy foie gras is topped with a crisp caramel crème brûlée crust: Jean-Georges Vongerichten’s pure-genius dish offers the best argument yet to keep fattening up geese (bring on the letters!). 1 Central Park West at Columbus Circle (212-299-3900). Part of the $95 prix fixe, or for $19 at the restaurant’s Nougatine.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

4. CHOCOLATE-CHIP WALNUT COOKIES AT LEVAIN BAKERY


More a landmass than a cookie, this six-ounce colossus is an orgy of walnuts, chocolate and enough butter to grease the engine of a 747. Served warm and just shy of raw, it is gooey, outrageous goodness per-cookie-fied. 167 W 74th St at Amsterdam Ave (212-874-6080). One cookie $3.75.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

5. DANDAN NOODLES AT SICHUAN CHENGDU


Heat-seekers: Trek to a fluorescent-lit mall in Flushing, Queens, and locate the stand slinging chewy dandan noodles. They’re chockablock with pickled vegetables, crumbled pork, peanuts, fiery chili oil and fragrant Szechuan peppercorns. Inside J & L Mall, 41-82 Main St between Maple and Sanford Aves, Flushing, Queens (no phone). $3.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

6. STEAMED BERKSHIRE PORK BUNS AT MOMOFUKU NOODLE BAR


Before David Chang became New York’s culinary poster boy, insiders flocked to his original noodle bar—for buns. The chef’s upscale riff on a classic Chinatown pork bun—a steamed, fluffy handful filled with fatty pork, hoisin and pickled cucumbers—remains the gold standard. 163 First Ave at 10th St (212-475-7899). $9 for two.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

7. BOMBOLONI AT FALAI PANETTERIA OR CAFFE FALAI


Iacopo Falai, the former Le Cirque pastry chef, crafts doughnuts from a yeast dough not unlike brioche; fills the airy puff with vanilla-specked pastry cream or jam; and rolls the parcel in sugar. Bonus: half off after 7pm. Panetteria: 9 Clinton St at Rivington St (212-777-8956). Caffe: 265 Lafayette St between Prince and Spring Sts (917-338-6207). $2.50 each.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

8. HAZELNUT SOUFFLÉ AT CAPSOUTO FRÈRES


Worth every second of the 20 minutes it takes to custom-make each one, Jacques Capsouto’s gossamer hazelnut soufflé has a dark, nutty aroma that balances the featherlight texture. 451 Washington St at Watts St (212-966-4900). $9.50.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

9. LATTE AT GORILLA COFFEE


You think the wait at Starbucks is long; Extraordinarily strong espresso and rich lattes draw eternal lines—worth waiting in. For those seeking a less-potent poison, try the Vermont-syrupy mild maple latte. 97 Fifth Ave at Park Pl, Park Slope, Brooklyn (718-230-3244). Medium latte: $3.50.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.


Photograph: Astrid Stawiarz

10. PIZZA BIANCA AT SULLIVAN STREET BAKERY


We know: two pizzas. But this doesn’t look or smell or taste like a pie. One bite of the rectangular flatbread reveals waves of flavor brought on by the simplest of ingredients: salt, olive oil and rosemary. 533 W 47th St between Tenth and Eleventh Aves (212-265-5580). $1.75 slice.

Download a printable checklist of all 100 selections.

Share your thoughts

  1. * mandatory fields

Comments & ratings

Rated as: 0/5 (0 ratings)
  • FOIE GRAS BRLE AT JEAN GEORGES - Tadda! I have finally completed the Top Ten Best Eats of..... . 2008! My birthday dinner at Jean Georges allowed me to put the check on this decadent dish. If goose organ could be a desert - which Richard Blais showed in the Top Chef finale - then th is is the tops. If you are not into dark meat, then it is hard to explain, but if you had this in a blind taste test, I think you agree with me that this is just plain god stuff. BTDT!

    Fuego Grande Thu Apr 7 2011
    Report
  • DANDAN NOODLES AT SICHUAN CHENGDU - After year's of mystery and myth, I have finally been able to lay to rest my question of whether these once revered noodles still exist. The sad answer i s - no. I finally trekked out to Flushing; which, for me, held an aura of mystique. It seems to be at the end of the earth (for manhattanites that is) yet is somehow an extension - if not the fullest manifestation - of New York's cosmopolitanism. The once legendary J&L Mall is no l onger and in its place is a large and certainly impressive chinese market. The positive outcom e of this quest is that once in Flushing the seas of culinary delights part for all comers on t heir quests.

    Fuego Grande Wed Dec 1 2010
    Report
75°
sponsored by

Search

Search