Authentic city restaurants versus suburban chain dining

Do chains deserve their bad rap? To find out, we pitted them against their “authentic” city counterparts in a blind taste of kid-friendly faves.
 (Photo: Jamie Kraus)
1/10
Photo: Jamie KrausTHE JUDGES FOR OUR TASTE TEST
2/10
THE JUDGES FOR OUR TASTE TESTTOC Associate Food & Drink Editor Julia Kramer (a Highland Park native pictured in her food critic disguise) Photo: Nicole Radja
3/10
City fave Lao Sze Chuan (2172 S Archer Ave, 312-326-5040), $11.45 Photo: Erica Gannett
4/10
Suburban chain Pei Wei (1021 N Elmhurst Rd, Mount Prospect; 847-704-4095), $8.25
5/10
City fave Jake Melnick’s Corner Tap (41 E Superior St, 312-266-0400), eight jumbo wings, $10.95 Photo: Nicole Radja
6/10
Suburban chain Buffalo Wild Wings (301 E Euclid Ave, Mount Prospect and multiple other locations; 847-255-5000), 12 medium wings, $9.29 Photo: Erica Gannett
7/10
City fave La Scarola (721 W Grand Ave, 312-243-1740), $13.95 Photo: Erica Gannett
8/10
Suburban chain Maggiano’s Little Italy (4999 Old Orchard Center, Skokie and other locations; 847-933-9555), $12.95 Photo: Nicole Radja
9/10
City fave Smoque (3800 N Pulaski Rd, 773-545-7427), full slab, $19.95; sliced brisket sandwich, $7.95 Photo: Erica Gannett
10/10
Suburban chain Famous Dave’s Barbecue (206B Yorktown Center, Lombard and other locations; 630-620-6363), full slab, $22.99; Texas beef brisket sandwich, $9.49 Photo: Nicole Radja
By Judy Sutton Taylor |
Advertising

The dish Orange chicken

City fave Lao Sze Chuan (2172 S Archer Ave, 312-326-5040), $11.45 

Suburban chain Pei Wei (1021 N Elmhurst Rd, Mount Prospect; 847-704-4095), $8.25

Stella says “I really like [Lao Sze Chuan’s] sauce. It’s not spicy and kind of sweet. The [Pei Wei chicken] is too dry. Of all the dishes, this is the one I’d pick [Lao Sze Chuan’s] to have again.”
Julia says “Neither is particularly a standout, orange chicken–wise. But the [Pei Wei] chicken is very bland. [Lao Sze Chuan’s] is a little gloopy, but it had a nice orange-y flavor.”
Winner Lao Sze Chuan

The dish Buffalo wings

City fave Jake Melnick’s Corner Tap (41 E Superior St, 312-266-0400), eight jumbo wings, $10.95

Suburban chain Buffalo Wild Wings (301 E Euclid Ave, Mount Prospect and multiple other locations; 847-255-5000), 12 medium wings, $9.29

Stella says “[Jake Melnick’s] wings are less chewy than the others, and more moist. They have a lot of flavor.”
Julia says “The [Jake Melnick’s] wings seem more heavily fried, and I like that. Stella’s right—the others are chewier; they have bigger bits of fat.”
Winner Jake Melnick’s

The dish Lasagna

City fave La Scarola (721 W Grand Ave, 312-243-1740), $13.95

Suburban chain Maggiano’s Little Italy (4999 Old Orchard Center, Skokie and other locations; 847-933-9555), $12.95

Stella says “There’s just too much cheese on the [La Scarola] one, and it’s really salty. And it doesn’t look as nice on the plate. But it’s still really flavorful.”
Julia says “Presentation-wise, [Maggiano’s] is the winner. It’s a more sophisticated-looking lasagna. And I like the layer of ricotta. But [La Scarola] is impressive, too. They’re both huge. If you ate an entire portion of either, it could kill you.”
Winner After lots of back-and-forth, Stella chose Maggiano’s. For Julia, it was a draw.

The dish St. Louis-style brisket and spare ribs

City fave Smoque (3800 N Pulaski Rd, 773-545-7427), full slab, $19.95; sliced brisket sandwich, $7.95

Suburban chain Famous Dave’s Barbecue (206B Yorktown Center, Lombard and other locations; 630-620-6363), full slab, $22.99; Texas beef brisket sandwich, $9.49

Stella says “[Smoque’s] brisket is too dry for me. For the ribs, the [Famous Dave’s] ones are meatier and very tender. I’d eat more.”
Julia says “[Smoque’s] ribs and brisket have a deeper smoke flavor—it depends on your preference, but that’s a positive for me. [Famous Dave’s] brisket is more juicy and tender. It tastes more like Jewish brisket.”
Winner This was the surprise upset: Stella preferred Famous Dave’s brisket and ribs. Julia liked both briskets for their different preparations, but declared Smoque the winner on ribs. 

Advertising
This page was migrated to our new look automatically. Let us know if anything looks off at feedback@timeout.com