Sarah's Key

Film
3 out of 5 stars
sarah_6.jpg

Time Out says

3 out of 5 stars
Rather depressingly, Kristin Scott Thomas has said in interviews that there’s less ageism in French cinema, leading to more demanding roles for an actress in her fifties. In ‘Sarah’s Key’, a (mostly) French-language drama, she gives yet another emotionally honest, prime-of-her-career performance. The film is adapted from a best-selling novel, knitting together – not altogether satisfyingly – two stories connected by a shameful episode in France’s past: the round-up in the summer of 1942 of 13,000 Jews in Paris not by Nazis, but by French police. Final destination: Auschwitz.

In the first story, it’s 1942 and the police arrive at the home of a Jewish girl, Sarah (Mélusine Mayance). She immediately sees through the weasel words of the officer and locks her brother in a cupboard, promising to return. Handheld cameras capture a kind of collective unhinging as terror grips the thousands thrown first in a city centre cycle track, the Vélodrome d’Hiver, then shunted to a transit camp.

Sixty years later, Scott Thomas is an American journalist living in France, researching a story on the round-up, who discovers that her husband’s grandparents possibly moved into Sarah’s flat weeks later in August 1942. The two halves are told concurrently, a structure that’s fine for a novel but too schematic on film, doing justice to neither story.

Scott Thomas is tremendous, though; the emotional detail of her performance is never less than gripping, even as the film falters. Shock, sympathy and the horrific realisation that she would have behaved no differently all pass across her face as she listens to the what-else-could-I-have-done complicity of her grandmother-in-law (‘Oh, it was the war. Everything was so confused’) or an elderly woman wearing a prominent crucifix whose flat overlooked the Vélodrome: ‘They fed us such lies about the Jews… Who would I tell? The police?’

Posted:

Details

Release details

Rated:
12A
Release date:
Friday August 5 2011
Duration:
110 mins

Cast and crew

Director:
Gilles Paquet-Brenner
Cast:
Kristin Scott Thomas
Melusine Mayance