Film
What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases
Bookmark this pageThe Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King (2003)
Director: Peter Jackson
Movie review
From Time Out Film Guide
The first thing we see is a maggot wriggling on the end of a hook, and behind it, the grinning face of Smeagol (Serkis). It's a typically incisive piece of picture-making and storytelling, taking us back before The Fellowship to a time of supposed innocence and the moment of corruption - the rediscovery of the ring on the river bed. What follows may be the longest climax in film history: more than three hours of mad kings, massing troops, battle cries and ballyhoo. In terms of spectacle, there's nothing like it. Jackson has weight of numbers on his side. But for the first time in this mammoth undertaking, the director seems overwhelmed by logistics - and if he isn't, we are. Return of the King is no less dynamic than the previous chapters, but too much of the dialogue sounds like an orientation exercise. Some story strands are crudely abbreviated; others fail to develop elements that were already well-established. Given the inordinate running time, it's hard to avoid the feeling that we've already been here, done this. As to how the trilogy's themes of leadership, self-sacrifice, loyalty and honour speak to our own troubling times, Tolkien's anti-fascist allegory doesn't allow for ambivalence or ambiguity.Author: TCh
User reviews of this film
-
- Brian said...
-
Posted on Dec 27 2008 23:37
I disagree with the last half of your review, particularly the allegory reference... the LOTR trilogy remained true to Tolkien's premise: the story is not an allegory. The only allegories are those the viewer decides to force upon history, which you seem to be keen on doing.
Other than that, honestly the film (and the LOTR series) is a masterpiece and will be highly-regarded in cinematic history, unlike your skewed review. - Report as inappropriate
-
- tom said...
- Posted on Oct 09 2008 04:05 The lord of the rings is a great masterpiece, no matter which way you view it as a book or as a movie. Peter Jackson delivered the main plot missing out the scouring of the shire and other events, which would have made the movie even better (but also longer). Best movie ever.
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Andrew said...
-
Posted on Sep 28 2008 13:44
I agree entirely with the reviewer, except about the allegory, which Tolkien said it wasn't.
Jackson reduced a fantastic story to a series of battle scenes between comic book baddies and tackily clad goodies (the Gondor knights' armours and Isildur's sord were particularly disappointing), preceded by rousing speeches or other displays of manly bravery and camaraderie. It was all so ineffectual and melodramatic. Especially jarring were all the endless teary-eyed scenes with Frodo.
In short, I'm really sorry for all you people who missed the visceral experience of reading the book without knowing where the story was going. - Report as inappropriate
-
- james said...
- Posted on Aug 28 2008 22:57 This is without doubt the best movie ever made. nothing will top this. ever.
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Adam said...
- Posted on Aug 15 2008 02:10 you sir are a complete failure. A masterpice has been layed before you and you shame it with nonsensical words of poor judgement.
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Brandon said...
- Posted on Mar 31 2008 23:32 wtf... do you even know what your talking about here buddy. Overwhelmed by logistics..., im sorry but all of your arguments show that you dont know what a masterpiece is when you see one.
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Myrthmor said...
- Posted on Feb 20 2008 23:15 You looked at all the wrong parts of the movie, and misinterpreted the delivery of the dialogue. That English actor, theatrical style isn't dull, it's masterful. It's just not yuppie like so many American action flicks.
- Report as inappropriate
-
- tim said...
- Posted on Feb 08 2008 00:59 Well said. One dimensional characters a good film does not make. I didn't realize ambivalence was a big word, but I guess to some it is...
- Report as inappropriate
-
- Jo said...
- Posted on Feb 01 2008 08:23 You are trying to mask the fact that you have no idea what your talking about with big words
- Report as inappropriate
Cast & crew
Director: Peter Jackson
Producer: Barrie M Osborne, Peter Jackson, Fran Walsh
Cast: Elijah Wood, Ian McKellen, Liv Tyler, Viggo Mortensen, Sean Astin, Cate Blanchett, John Rhys-Davies, Bernard Hill, Billy Boyd, Dominic Monaghan, Orlando Bloom, Hugo Weaving, Miranda Otto, David Wenham, Andy Serkis, Ian Holm, Sean Bean full cast
Genre(s): Epics
Rated: 12A
Duration: 201 mins
Most popular on this site
Top Stories
The ultimate 'Harry Potter' crib sheet
Our resident potter professor, Wally Hammond, offers the ultimate introduction to 'Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince'
Bruno is here!
Sacha Baron Cohen hits the streets as Austria's premiere gay fashionista in 'Bruno'. Read our review of the film plus see the pics from our cover shoot
Lars von Trier's 'Antichrist': joke or masterpiece?
Dave Calhoun invites seven experts to watch Lars von Trier's latest and share their reactions
Classic Film Club: 'Smiles of a Summer Night'
Each week Tom Huddleston watches a classic film he's never seen before. The rules are simple: each film must be considered a masterpiece and each must be completely new to him.
Has Michael Mann lost it?
Adam Lee Davies mourns the passing of a major Hollywood talent as Michael Mann's 'Public Enemies' sees the great director running on empty
Why 'Ice Age 3' is really for adults
Tom Huddleston takes a look at a selection of films which bring adult problems to a pre-teen audience
Is this Summer 2009's best film?
The French filmmaker Claire Denis speaks to Dave Calhoun about her new film, '35 Shots of Rum', a tender portrait of a father-daughter relationship in Paris
Outdoor film screenings in London 2009
Derek Adams offers a guide to the best places to see films outside in London this summer
50 essential sci-fi films
With 'Star Trek' making serious waves, we thought it would be a perfect time to select 50 must-see sci-fi films
What do you think?
Post your review now