Time Out says
Dir. Neill Blomkamp (2013, 120 minutes). Cast: Matt Damon, Jodie Foster, Sharlto Copley, Alice Braga. Opens Aug 22.
Something about this first US studio feature from the South African-born director of ‘District 9’ just doesn’t feel right. While Neill Blomkamp’s 2009 debut was a bracing blast of whipsmart sci-fi, the work of a committed writer-director with talent and integrity to burn, ‘Elysium’ feels like the product of a cautious Hollywood committee. It retains the action-movie-with-a-social-conscience template of ‘District 9’ but ditches that film’s sense of dizzying, anything-goes vitality.
Matt Damon is sturdy – if a little faceless – as the futuristic blue-collar grunt whose life nosedives when he receives a fatal-in-five-days radioactive blast at work. His only hope is to get to Elysium, the orbiting paradise reserved exclusively for the rich and heartless, run by Jodie Foster’s clipped, frosty and unconvincingly French CEO.
There are moments in ‘Elysium’ which recapture the breath-stopping intensity of Blomkamp’s debut, most of them involving South African actor Sharlto Copley as a mangled Afrikaans mercenary, the only character here with any spark. The special effects are uniformly superb, and a handful of action sequences – including a magnificent mid-film Smart car heist – justify the price of admission.
But this is a messy, poorly structured film, riddled with plot holes and lacking any kind of satisfying conclusion. Perhaps it’s another case of raised expectations: from a first-timer, ‘Elysium’ might seem more exciting. But in the wake of ‘District 9’, we’re all too aware what this risk-taking filmmaker is capable of, and it’s far more than this conceptually bold, sporadically engaging but ultimately bland blockbuster. Tom Huddleston