Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

Jindabyne (2006)

Director: Ray Lawrence

Average user rating

3 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

She’s dead. They can’t help her. Best to leave her in the water where at least she’ll be preserved. Such is the argument when four Aussie mates encounter a corpse floating in a remote pool and decide to hold off reporting their discovery until after their annual fishing weekend in a rugged corner of New South Wales. Garage owner Stewart (Gabriel Byrne) doesn’t even mention it to his wife (Laura Linney) on his return, and when the news does leak out it doesn’t just exacerbate tensions in their already rocky marriage, it exposes the cultural abyss between the white fishermen and the appalled family of the Aboriginal victim. For the indigenous communities, the spirit lives on after the body, so this is an upsetting act of disrespect, and the perpetrators seem uncomprehendingly insensitive.

Like his previous film ‘Lantana’, Lawrence’s latest uses the shock of mortality to send dramatic ripples off in all directions, though here the scope’s even wider than that film’s engrossing survey of the battle of the sexes, taking in an array of lives stymied by both personal and colonial histories, suggesting that the scars of racism are far from healed and even that white Australians are interlopers in this imposing terrain. Thankfully, there’s little preachiness in these waves of complexity, since the film is grounded in the emotional immediacy of Byrne’s befuddled masculinity and the reliably brilliant Linney’s counter-productive rage at small-town narrow-mindedness. Although you could argue that the ending’s unpersuasively over-resolved given the myriad divisive issues raised by Beatrix Christian’s probing screenplay, the seamless overall blend of involving domestic turmoil and haunted national self-questioning is quite some achievement.

Author: Trevor Johnston 2007-05-22 10:33:12

Time Out London Issue 1918: May 23rd-29th 2007

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Technoguy said...

Posted on Dec 31 2007 19:25 I watched this wondering why if they're making a film on such an indigenous subject eg Aborigine's beliefs and customs they used an American(Linney) and an Irish(Byrne) to play the main roles.However that said I did warm to Byrne but not to Linney>She seems too polished in these Middle class angst roles that she seemed to blanket all her responses in a role that should have been livelier. The support cast were good and the Aborigines.Most of all I liked the marvellous ,beautiful Australian landscape which is all-enveloping.Transplanting stories to different countries doesn't always work but this one did,from an original Raymond Carver story.

Report as inappropriate
Fat Owl said...

Posted on Aug 19 2007 19:05 Hugely dissapointing. A fantastic opportunity wasted through complete lack of engaging direction. It's all very well to explore emotions but there's a reason why there are rules about film-making to do with pace and action.

Report as inappropriate
Nicky said...

Posted on Jul 13 2007 10:26 Takes a bit of time to get going but when it does absolutely superb

Report as inappropriate