Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

Three Monkeys (2008)

Director: Nuri Bilge Ceylan

Time Out rating

Average user rating

6 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

Flush the histrionics and ‘real-life’ struggles of awards-season movies out of your system with a dose of invigorating art cinema from Turkish filmmaker Nuri Bilge Ceylan. With ‘Three Monkeys’, Ceylan moves away from minimalist, self-reflective explorations of the lives of rural-born intellectuals who are struggling in the metropolis (‘Clouds of May’, ‘Uzak’, ‘Climates’) to investigate a plot that could easily leap off the page of a pulpish crime thriller.

Taciturn, working-class patriarch Eyüp (Yavuz Bingol) acquiesces when his politician boss Servet (Ercan Kesal) runs over and kills a stranger on a country road and asks his employee to serve time in jail on his behalf. While Eyüp is in jail, his wife Hacer (Hatice Aslan) and teenage son Ismail (Rifat Sungar), who live in a suburban flat by a menacing sea, manage to turn a difficult family set-up into a situation that borders on the furthest reaches of dysfunction. Both Ismail and Hacer find themselves in the pay of Servet – to the extent that when Eyüp returns from jail a few months later, the natural order of their household is broken forever. There’s a hint of a return to sad normality later on, but only at the expense of a horrible pact that leaves a sour taste in the mouth regarding the extent of human venality.

Ceylan is a director who can find the blackest of humour in the darkest of corners and, we now know, can pinpoint the subtlest of gestures in the most melodramatic of stories. The interesting thing about this experiment is that on the surface Ceylan’s fifth feature, which won Best Director at Cannes, is his most mainstream yet. However, in telling a wild, tragic story that hinges on man’s constant ability to find a weaker fellow to prey on, he relies on less obvious tools than most filmmakers would: silence, close-ups, the subtle manipulation of colours, clever sound design and breathtaking composition. While favouring reality over fantasy, he still manages to lend his film, which is blessed with a crisp, autumnal palette of greens and yellows and browns, a vivid sense of the universal and the theatrical by setting it largely in one bold location – a simple apartment at the top of a concrete block – over which we intermittently hear thunder crack and see lightning flicker.

As with Ceylan’s other films, this is cinema that requires patience and attention, but the rewards are many. It’s not entirely successful. There are moments when the demands of the plot rub up against Ceylan’s more ascetic instincts, and there are longueurs that frustrate. But this is a fascinating transitional film from an intriguing director at the top of his game.

Author: Dave Calhoun 2009-02-10 11:30:41

Time Out London Issue 2008, 12 -18 February, 2008

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Jan Krebs said...

Posted on Apr 25 2009 04:00 Artily smug. Dishonest.

Report as inappropriate
Barry Solomons said...

Posted on Mar 25 2009 10:34 What a boring, mind-numbing, depressing film...The story of a feckless family indulging the whim of a corrupt politician...I am getting used to being disappointed with previews which extol an intriguing plot, brilliant direction and hidden meanings, in a 'must see' film!...Why don't professional previewers relate to the common, everyday cinemagoer and tell it how it really is, not how 'arty' and clever they are, recommending films which may only be appreciated by those with an interest in either Freud or Kirkegaard!...I like to emerge from the cinema either feeling happy or having my thoughts provoked...In my humble opinion, I thought the Three Monkeys was tiresome, self-indulgent and meaningless....Barry Solomons, Manchester

Report as inappropriate
Jane said...

Posted on Mar 07 2009 18:04 Extraordinary and brave - a film trusts and invests in the sensitivity of its audience. It opens up a almost dream like, comtemplative spaces, very close to dispear.
Ultimately both beautiful and life affirming. And it gives me faith in the future of cinema ar

Report as inappropriate
Jane said...

Posted on Mar 07 2009 18:04 Extraordinary and brave - a film trusts and invests in the sensitivity of its audience. It opens up a almost dream like, comtemplative spaces, very close to dispear.
Ultimately both beautiful and life affirming. And it gives me faith in the future of cinema.

Report as inappropriate
Michael Harding said...

Posted on Mar 01 2009 08:25 A film that cries out for a good editor. Over-long with some pointless exposition that leads nowhere. Beautiful, but ultimately self-indulgent. Although we are fans of Ceylan's work, we were disappointed. Superior to many films out there, no doubt, but could/should have been better.

Report as inappropriate
Ayham Laham said...

Posted on Nov 05 2008 14:06 This film represents the real art of cinema

Report as inappropriate