Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Updates:

Il Divo (2008)

Director: Paulo Sorrentino

Time Out rating

Average user rating

9 reviews

Movie review

From Time Out London

Cracking an enigma: that’s the mission that Italian director Paolo Sorrentino sets himself with his third film, a slick but never superficial portrait of the much accused, never convicted Italian politician Giuilio Andreotti. He served as a Christian Democrat prime minister seven times from the 1970s to the ’90s and his career hit its crucifixion and resurrection in the late 1990s and early 2000s when he was tried both for having connections to the Mafia and for instigating the murder of a journalist. He was judged guilty of the latter but had his conviction overturned on appeal. Now 90, he remains in the Italian senate.

It’s safe to say that Sorrentino doesn’t side with his country’s judicial system: his stunning film, which couldn’t be less of a traditional biopic if it tried, with its unsettling clash of the classical and the modern, from the music (Vivaldi, Trio) to the mise-en-scène (Antonioni meets car adverts), squarely places Andreotti in the centre of a sinister network of politics, business, religion and crime. An opening montage of violent deaths, including ‘God’s banker’ Roberto Calvi hanging from Blackfriars Bridge, speaks volumes about the film’s attitude to its subject. The first half is a speedy onslaught of episodes in Andreotti’s later life that culminates in a barrage of accusations – surely the film’s conscience – from a journalist. The second half slows down slightly and tightens its focus on the approach to his trial, the endless flashbulbs in his face a sinister contrast with a demeanour that couldn’t be less suggestive of celebrity.

Actor Toni Servillo, the lead in Sorrentino’s first film, ‘The Consequences of Love’ (2004), plays Andreotti as a walking corpse, a shuffling, silent, migraine-afflicted mystery. He’s surrounded by the more colourful members of his ‘faction’ and carries the physical awkwardness of a schoolboy. He’s almost a caricature with his gargoyle ears, his hunched back and his deathly movements – he glides like a Hoover in slo-mo. But there’s enough compassion to make this more than a cartoon: indeed, there’s enough in one scene in which Andreotti watches a crooner on television with his wife. Briefly we see behind the mask of his public persona.

Unless you’re closely acquainted with Italian politics, it’s unlikely that the onslaught of names and allusions to politicians, the Mafia, P2 (the anti-communist Masonic lodge) and the business world will entirely compute. But that doesn’t matter: Sorrentino’s skill is to tell his story almost entirely visually. The telling is breathtaking, a showy, musical dance that somehow bombards you with facts but limits dialogue to a minimum. Sorrentino surprises with every new shot, camera move, juxtaposition, snippet of humour and dollop of dread. As character assassination, it’s delicious and deadly.

Author: Dave Calhoun 2009-03-17 11:04:07

Time Out London Issue 2013 , March 19 - 25, 2009

Bookmark

User reviews of this film

Ron Berisha said...

Posted on Sep 15 2009 14:24 Diappointing. Il Divo fails to capture the complexity, the extraordinary intelligence, the ingenuity of Andreotti. It just ridicules him in a stylish way, that's it. This is Sorrentino wanting to walk the "Fellini-way", but tripping and falling; he should've stuck to the "Consequences of Love" type of thing, which was excellent, I thought. No wonder this film so highly acclaimed in UK; we love to see the Italian politicians (and the Vatican) as mafioso caricatures. There is more to it than that.

Report as inappropriate
Nigel Ings said...

Posted on May 15 2009 14:48 Il Divo restored my flagging faith in film, both as an art form and its capacity to make an intelligent statement on our cultural and political condition. Visually stunning, with a brilliant matching soundtrack, the complexity and subtlety of the narrative is more than sufficiently clear even for non speakers of Italian. Intellectually and emotionally satisfying, this is what film is all about.

Report as inappropriate
Paul Wilson said...

Posted on Mar 29 2009 22:29 Very disappointing. For all its verve, the great score, and the intriguing character of Andreotti, I found it was far too fragmented and lacking any useful plot drivers, hopping from one satirical scene to the next with neither reason nor consequence. Even leaving aside the bewildering dive into Italian political namedropping, it felt confusing, jumpy and ultimately tiresome. My girlfriend hated it too. And it was her idea to see it.

Report as inappropriate
Peter Ludbrook said...

Posted on Mar 28 2009 21:13 I was really looking forward to this film because in the past I've much enjoyed Italian political films like 'Illustrious Corpses' and 'The Mattei Affair'. Despite many excellent things in the film, particularly the central performance of the inscrutable, enigmatic Andreotti I found this disappointing. The style of the film did not illuminate the convoluted and labyrinthine relationship between the state, the Mafia and the Vatican. It confused it. I also found the subtitles extremely hard to follow and it might have been better to have completely rethought them for non-Italian audiences. Interesting but disappointing.

Report as inappropriate
Trigger said...

Posted on Mar 26 2009 15:49 Looks suspiciously like Fabio Capello to me. anybody else?

Report as inappropriate
Brian Damage said...

Posted on Mar 26 2009 10:32 I loved this film. The story was told with great style . I loved the way that the actors expressed themselves in the subtle use of body language with an economy of dialogue. My only gripe would be that the subtitles were difficult to follow at times because they kept jumping around but there wasn't really a way around that.

Report as inappropriate
ian said...

Posted on Mar 25 2009 22:30 No disagreement on the stylistic bravura here, a baroque tour de force of film-making. But as an exposition it is sorely lacking, and you give up after a while trying to figure out the absurd labyrinth of Itallian politics. Maybe that's ok for some, but I really needed some idea of what was actually going on. too clever by half, over stylised, even if you can admire the style.

Report as inappropriate
barry norman said...

Posted on Mar 24 2009 15:30 I loved this. For once, the style doesn't intrude on the narrative but, rather, augments it. At times it would help to be able to understand Italian, cos theres a lot of information to take in, but I say unto you- go with the flow, cats. check. it out.

Report as inappropriate
Jeff Makor said...

Posted on Mar 22 2009 16:03 European cinema has an approach to story telling in which style and humour takes precedence over glamour, celebrity and effect.
I will be seeing this movie if only to bask in something other than the gloss and cheap perfume of media expectation.

Report as inappropriate