Film

What's on at the cinema plus reviews of the latest movie and DVD releases

Up (2009)

Time Out rating

Average user rating

17 reviews

Synopsis

Not to be confused with the Russ Meyer/Roger Ebert bongo classic, 'Up' is the latest work from the Disney/Pixar stable about an old man who attaches balloons to the roof of his house so it lifts into the sky.

Movie review

From Time Out London

Pixar’s latest animated marvel may not reach the same heights of wonderment as a ‘Wall-E’ or a ‘Ratatouille’, but those are tough boots to fill and this short, sharp and sweet fantasy still manages to reaffirm its makers as world leaders in the kind of popular animation that embraces ideas and the real world alongside fun and fantasy. There’s just one problem: how do you wipe away a tear while wearing those chunky 3D glasses?

Neither a rat nor a robot, the film’s hero is Carl Fredricksen (voiced by Edward Asner), an elderly man of Middle America who as a youth dreamed of becoming an explorer like Amundsen or Scott. Work and family took over, years passed, and now he’s a long-faced widower, living in an old-fashioned home right in the middle of a metropolis. White-haired, square-jawed and stout, he looks like a more homely version of an older Norman Mailer. To outsiders he appears a frail grump, but we know he’s mourning his wife and – in some ways – his life.

The film is co-directed by Pixar stalwarts Pete Docter and Bob Peterson and – like ‘Wall-E’ before it – knows the value of silence as well as the need for souped-up action episodes to keep kids awake. As in ‘Wall-E’, too, the most grown-up stuff comes early: a brilliant, melancholy chapter, free of talk, runs through Carl’s life from boyhood to dotage, its triumphs and disappointments: it’s a staggeringly effective, sad sequence.

The story begins as the authorities threaten to place Carl in care after he has a scrap with a property developer looking to bulldoze his home. Carl’s response to this bureaucratic heavy-handedness is a bugle call to the gods of animation. He ties a thousand balloons to his home and floats off, house and all, to South America to find the waterfalls which he and his wife always dreamed of visiting. But he doesn’t bargain on a passenger. In tow is Russell, a podgy child and a wilderness explorer, who wants to help Carl cross a road so that he can win an achievement badge.The balloons are a showcase for modern digital animation as they convincingly float and shimmer; the jungle, too, is a canvas for an explosion of colours and various strange beasts.

There’s a touch of ‘Fitzcarraldo’ as Carl and Russell drag this old man’s home through a jungle while fighting off the maniacal ambitions of an even more elderly adventurer who lives in the wilderness. It’s not the only element of ‘Up’ that recalls Herzog’s determination to show nature laughing in the face of man. It’s a running theme – and gag – throughout. And there’s even something of Timothy Treadwell from ‘Grizzly Man’ about wide-eyed Russell.
So, Pixar triumphs again with a delirious fantasy that has one leg in the human world of hopes dashed and realised, and the other in the cartoon tradition of journeying and adventure. The crisp 3D is never gimmicky and the entire film is blessed with the light and air of bright but never gaudy colours.

Watch our interview with co-director Pete Docter and producer Jonas Rivera

Author: Dave Calhoun

Time Out London Issue 2042: 8 - 15 October, 2009

Email Tweet Share

User reviews of this film

emil omer said...

Posted on Dec 05 2011 14:04 very good moive only give this 1 stars

Report as inappropriate
tara said...

Posted on Mar 21 2011 14:03 well i thought it was strange lol

Report as inappropriate
Gareth said...

Posted on Mar 12 2010 15:29 Quite simply the best film I have seen for a long time. Moving, funny and intelligent.

Report as inappropriate
dangarrob said...

Posted on Jan 19 2010 10:14 I agree with Paul in that this is definitelly below standard Pixar. I do not understand all the hype about it when it came right after "Wall-E" which is a true masterpiece and should have been enough to make good a comparison. These are two very different films, surely, but when Wall-E had magic and moments of pure brilliance, "Up" can only give provide with a vague sense of nostalgia for the life of the protagonist. the premise is strong enough i.e. The will to make dreams and promises come true even after someone's death...but once the baloons have taken off the film goes into B-series territory with no purpose, barren and simplistic. Shame on you Disney

Report as inappropriate
Graham G said...

Posted on Nov 01 2009 15:30 A, funny, bittersweet and beautiful film, just the opening back-story of Carl's meeting and life lived with his wife Ellie had me choking on tears (and I am, as you may have noticed, a man). I am not automatically enthusiastic about Pixar's output - they've never made a truly bad film but Cars, for example, was surprisingly average. UP is a triumphant return to Pixar's best form, please do not miss it, but if you posess even a shred of humanity be prepared to have your emotions wrenched in every conceivable direction - including UP, of course...

Report as inappropriate
Lucy said...

Posted on Oct 29 2009 09:15 I think Paul must have seen a different film to the rest of us! This has to be the best film I've seen in years! Like the others have said, I was bawling my eyes out after 5 minutes, and then laughing hysterically 5 minutes after that. Everyone should go and see this film, even if it means taking a day off work...

Report as inappropriate
Manders said...

Posted on Oct 27 2009 22:28 This movie reaches a different level of children's movies. The 4 minute sequence depicting Carl and Ellie's life was incredibly moving for a cartoon, and subtle which meant that my children could not understand why I was crying, If you have lived and loved you will not be able to watch this film without crying. At the same time it is beautfully flimed with brilliant colours, has lots of action and a story to keep you gripped. It is a many layered story - the link between the devil living at Paradise is an age old twist,and nicely done. I loved it, as did my 8 & 10 year old, it is one of my all time favourite movies.

Report as inappropriate
molly farrell said...

Posted on Oct 26 2009 00:55 absolutely in my top 5 movies of all times.. very poignant for me having just lost a very beloved dad so film probably took on a different meaning for me in that it expressed my dad's life of living a good and fruitful life and tsking pride of place in serving others. The adventure of Life is to live life and live for and with others...

Report as inappropriate
Robert said...

Posted on Oct 23 2009 09:10 The critic has got this woefully wrong, this film is in a completely different league to 'Ratatouille' and even manages to surpass 'Wall-E' in just about every area. Without a doubt one of the best animated films I have ever seen. The characters are engaging, the story well written and executed. The film is an emotional roller coaster - when you're not crying of sadness you're crying of laughter. Loved every minute of it - and I'm a bit of a grumpy sod so that's saying something!

Report as inappropriate
Rob said...

Posted on Oct 12 2009 11:58 I actually think that Pixar have raised the bar another level above Wall-E with this. It was a wonderful movie - superb characters, incredibly moving and the funniest animated feature yet. As the reviewer stated, the sequence showing Carl's life was staggering, and I thought the 'Dogs Playing Poker' pastiche was worth the entrance fee alone! This is close to perfect.

Report as inappropriate
Abigail G said...

Posted on Oct 12 2009 09:07 Few reviewers warn you about the almost unbearable poignancy of the first 20 mins of this movie which show the love story, and final parting, of Carl and his childhood sweetheart Ellie. I was so wiped out by this the rest of the movie largely passed me by to be honest. Terribly moving. Only go see it with someone you can cry in front of comfortably.

Report as inappropriate
KFH said...

Posted on Oct 10 2009 17:45 Moving, beautifully animated, adventure story about friendship and love. It had me crying and laughing from the first few minutes, while the second half kept me gripped with a stream of dramatic, breathtaking adventure sequences perfect for showcasing the 3D animation. Fantastic. Thoroughly recommend for adults and kids alike. I strongly suggest seeing it in 3D.

Report as inappropriate
Paul said...

Posted on Oct 09 2009 20:58 A couple of good reviews got me out in the rain to see this film and frankly I wish I hadn't bothered. Perhaps its the Disney effect or just that Pixar have lost it, but this is a tired rehash of traditional Amercian cartoon themes that never really got off the ground.
Disney demand cute kid, cute animals,funny voices and things to productise in abundance, forgetting the need for a strong script. Up is no different.
No clever dialogue or interesting characterterisations beyond behaps the dogs. If you like watching your dog poo on the pavement and buy it toys then this is probably the cartoon for you. It's a great shame because Pixar can be good, but this is below standard. One to take the kids to, but don't expect too many laughs for the grown-ups.

Report as inappropriate
ancient UK said...

Posted on Oct 09 2009 19:52 took more than long enough for this film to hit the UK. again, months and months behind we are.

Report as inappropriate
Stafford said...

Posted on Jun 10 2009 17:35 WOO HOO!

Report as inappropriate