The Lovely Bones (12A)

Film

Drama

741.fi.x491.lovely.jpg

Time Out rating:

<strong>Rating: </strong>2/5

User ratings:

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5
Rate this  

Time Out says

Tue Feb 16 2010

Anyone hoping that Peter Jackson may have returned to the more intimate territory of 1994’s ‘Heavenly Creatures’ for his version of Alice Sebold’s novel must resign themselves to the fact that Jackson’s filmmaking DNA may have become irreversibly modified. The source material might be more down to earth than ‘King Kong’, but Jackson does everything in his power to ditch the real in favour of fantasy.

The book was narrated from the grave by Susie Salmon (played by Saoirse Ronan in the film), a 14-year-old girl who is raped and murdered near her home. From a vantage point between heaven and earth, Susie follows her parents (Mark Wahlberg, Rachel Weisz), her sister (Rose McIver) and her killer, Mr Harvey (Stanley Tucci), as she – and they – struggle to accept her fate. Not that we see anyone raped or murdered in this $100 million, 12A version: Jackson fatally softens the edges of the tragedy and its fallout.

The real let-down is the film’s reliance on overblown effects to represent Susie’s limbo. Coming across as if Dali was commissioned to paint Middle Earth for the New Zealand tourist board, the CGI scenes sideline the cast in favour of the magic of the animator’s hard drive. And it doesn’t help that a gin-swigging Susan Sarandon plays Susie’s grandmother for comic effect just when you feel the film could do with some weight. And who’s telling this story? It should be Susie, and at points she narrates. But there’s no consistency.

Is she a ghost? A narrator? A heroine? A victim? Her chocolate-box world suggests it’s a 14-year-old’s view of life. Yet there are entire sections when we forget Susie’s all-seeing eye and don’t know whether we’re in a drama, a thriller or a horror.

Watch this confused, unhappy film and weep a little for Lynne Ramsay (‘Ratcatcher’), the British director who was first commissioned to write and direct it before it was swept away from her by higher powers.
35

Comments

Add +

Release details

Rated:

12A

UK release:

Fri Feb 19 2010

Duration:

139 mins

Share your thoughts
  1. * mandatory fields

Comments & ratings

Rated as: 3/5 (23 ratings)
  • Susie Salmon has the once in a lifetime misfortune to live opposite a multiple serial killer who lures her into a secret Fritzl inspired dirt dungeon out on the edge of the forest. School's over, it's getting misty dark, cold so Susie takes the short cut across the lonely corn fields - hey you kids, I'm telling you, don't do that, right! Susie must get to heaven but meanwhile she's stuck in a blue yonder limbo between earth and the ever after - where she aims to influence events ensuring George Harvey, her killer, gets it in the neck. But George is a sly old psychopath who's always just about slipping through the flexible arms of the law. The Susie scenes, in the not quite heaven, are dragged out too much with the usual dream like landscapes straight outta the Wizard of Oz. Rachel Weisz as mum and Susan Saradon as the almost still sexy grandma are both pumping out good scenes that carry the film along nicely when the will-he-won't-he be caught tensions get too much.

    Violetta Thu Mar 4 2010
    Rated as: 4/5
    Report
  • Did go to see film after all and wish i had gone to see Wolfman instead! Yes thought it was a bit long winded too and found the fantasy, otherworld bits far too long. Not really my cup of tea!

    barnsleygirl1 Thu Mar 4 2010
    Rated as: 2/5
    Report
  • Film ok, just a bit long winded.

    filmweasel Wed Mar 3 2010
    Rated as: 2/5
    Report
  • I was actually going to see it tonight bt after reading the poor reviews i don't know if i will! I like ilms with lots of tension, twists and a really uncomfortable ending. Does this film have any of these things?

    barnsleygirl1 Wed Mar 3 2010
    Rated as: 1/5
    Report
  • Really good film, sad but very enjoyable.

    Jayne M Mon Mar 1 2010
    Rated as: 4/5
    Report
  • I thought this was good. Not a lot of tension really, not really quite sure where the story was supposed to be going, and the end was anti-climactic, but it avoided falling into some of the traps of predictability and corniness which plague many movies. Very interesting aesthetically, and reasonably thought-provoking.

    _Matt_1977_ Fri Feb 26 2010
    Rated as: 3/5
    Report
  • the book is impossible to film but jackson has to be appreciated for his sincere passion and the ingenious visual design and a stunning performance by ronan -she is totally hypnotic as the spirit stuck in a nightmarish idylllic surreal universe -i found it quite intriguing though it is rather slow and the other characters have very little to do other than tucci -but worth a look whether you have or not reaD THE BOOK

    usman khawaja Thu Feb 25 2010
    Rated as: 3/5
    Report
  • This was only on my list of movies to see because of Stanley Tucci’s Oscar nomination. I really wish I hadn’t bothered. This movie is puerile pap. It feels like a cheesey 1970’s “Jackieâ€� magazine murder mystery for not very bright teenage girls. Some of the plot’s toe-curlingly awful, as is the CGI, as is the narration, etc. Alas, there’s some seriously good acting talent going to waste here. I predict this one will be on sale in the DVD bargain bin for around £2 within 6 months.

    Dicky Wed Feb 24 2010
    Rated as: 1/5
    Report
  • good film u could hear a pin drop all the way through fast paced attention grabbing had everything in it family fun and drama first love romance close your eyes gory bits(enough 4 me) in between fantasy bits with lovely special effects few tears laughs with gran edge of your seats bits i am what u would call a more senior person i have lost people i loved one suddenly we do hope they stayed around a while to say goodbye and i am slightly spiritual so i was tuned in nicely to this film message from this film let go of the past live 4 today dont be afraid of tomrrow

    jan Tue Feb 23 2010
    Rated as: 4/5
    Report
  • I really enjoyed this film. The story was good and it was a sad film. Worth a watch =)

    Jen Mon Feb 22 2010
    Rated as: 5/5
    Report
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  • Hotwise
  • Cool brands
  • Star