Anna Calvi – 'One Breath' album review

It's full of interesting breakdowns and textures, but the London musician's second record is as controlled as her first



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

Fittingly for an artist who rose from music grad obscurity to art rock fame as fast as Nick Cave could say ‘Fancy a support slot?’, Anna Calvi does love a dramatic crescendo. Her Mercury-nominated 2011 debut was dense with them: her cold, quivering, gun metal grey vocal was repeatedly set to ‘gale force’ and the raw echoing drums to ‘gallop’, while her hand whirled up storm after storm by circling rather than strumming the strings of her Jeff Buckley-referencing Fender Telecaster.

Her sound, given a sort of hollowed intensity by the lack of a bass player in her band, certainly made an impression, and she drew legit (if not quite level) comparisons to PJ Harvey and Siouxsie And The Banshees – but over several singles it all felt a bit strained. Despite the grandeur of the red-and-black, flamenco-inspired stage aesthetic and weighty influences from Maria Callas to Ravel to film director Wong Kar Wei, all those crescendos started to have the converse effect. It was possible to leave Calvi’s live shows feeling no more genuinely epic than if you’d just saved a tenner on car insurance with MoneySuperMarket.

Album number two, far more interestingly, experiments with breakdowns. Recorded in a few short weeks with producer John Congleton (chosen for his previous work with Amanda Palmer and Bill Callahan) and influenced by the death of a loved one, ‘One Breath’ is no less intense than its predecessor. But it shifts the focus from lust to loss, desire to depression – and it includes some striking moments in which songs, the Anita Lane-ishly sensual title track included, dismantle themselves before your ears.

Opener and new single ‘Suddenly’ throws an Arcade Fire-style upsurge crashing down the stairs at the two-minute mark, as Calvi's voice peters into a whisper: ‘Ashes to ash, it leaves me with nothing.’ ‘Carry Me Over’ frames a great pop melody with violent guitar squalls, anxious plucking and what may or may not be a piano dying in a damp cave. Meanwhile ‘Piece By Piece’ – a song about the process of forgetting, incorporating a Hot Chip-esque bass line, Calvi’s most quietly seductive vocal to date and a moving lyric about scent fading from her collar – dismembers a passing orchestra as it goes.

‘One Breath’ succeeds in Calvi's stated intention to ‘work more with textures’: ‘Tristan’, which sounds like the lovechild of Bat For Lashes and Mark Lanegan, sees her whacking her guitar strings with a stick and turning her voice into a descending peal of bells. But if you found Calvi a bit hammy the first time round, the freshly expressed instability and fragility isn’t likely to change that. The breakdowns, like those crescendos, sound like controlled acts of theatre.

Buy this album here

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Listen to Anna Calvi on Spotify

Watch the video for 'Eliza'

Users say


Read more music features

Interview: Gerard Way

The My Chemical Romance singer talks Britpop, Bowie and board games

Ten acts you need to know about in 2015

You’ll be hearing great things from these up-and-coming bands, singer-songwriters, producers and artists throughout this year

The Time Out music quiz 2014

Test your knowledge of the year’s musical highlights, from Kanye and Kim to Kiesza and Kate Bush

The 50 best songs of 2014

Stick this playlist on repeat – it’s the very best new music of the last 12 months

The 30 best albums of 2014

Discover some great new music as we take a look back at this year’s top albums

See all Time Out music features