Birdy – 'Fire Within' album review

The young singer finds her own voice on her second album of downbeat pop



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

It’s hard to remember a time when talent shows weren’t such a huge part of popular culture: when we rarely used to see the painstaking process of manufacturing a pop star. But that process still happens behind the scenes as much as it does on TV. Birdy, aka Jasmine van den Bogaerde, kept her profile comparatively low when she began her career in 2008. Aged just 12, she won Future Music Management’s (untelevised) ‘Open Mic UK’ competition. Then, in 2011, she released her eponymous debut album on Atlantic, on which she swooned through a cover of The XX’s ‘Shelter’, sung a strained version of Bon Iver’s ‘Skinny Love’ and put her own sombre imprint on ‘1901’ by Phoenix. These reproductions were perfectly pleasant, but there was nothing of Birdy in the record other than her vocals.

With this second LP, however, the songstress proves she’s more than just a voice. There are touches of Coldplay’s epicness in the sweeping chords of opener and single ‘Wings’ and hints of Adele’s range on the gutsy ‘All You Never Say’. Further into the album, ‘Words as a Weapon’ shows off melancholy violins and plucked mandolin that were undoubtedly inspired by her co-writer, Mumford And Sons’ Ben Lovett.

As well as Lovett, Birdy has had Ryan Tedder (who’s written for Beyoncé) helping out, along with Muse producer Rich Costey and Rage Against The Machine bassist Tim Commerford. With talent like that on hand, ‘Fire Within’ was never going to be a terrible album – but has the music industry machine managed to produce some more than mediocre here?

Yes, actually. This collection of touching originals reveals Birdy’s listening habits and, more importantly, her personality. That’s something we don’t get time to register with ‘X Factor’ megastars such as One Direction, whose urgent poppiness feels like a bombardment. The fact that we didn’t witness Birdy’s every move in making the genuine and considered effort that is ‘Fire Within’, doesn’t mean she shouldn’t take her place in the pop pantheon.

Buy this album here

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Listen to Birdy on Spotify

Watch the video for ‘Wings’

Users say


Read more music features

Interview: Mary J Blige

The queen of R&B flew half way around the world to record her new album with London’s brightest young musicians. We met her in Whitehall to find out why

Interview: The National

‘Sometimes I forget I have the same job as Madonna.’ Matt Berninger, frontman for the brooding indie stars, looks back on 18 months of touring

Interview: Lorde

‘I don’t look good smiling, so I don’t smile.’ Lorde has been 2014’s most exciting enigma. We talk to the teen queen who’s saved pop from itself

Interview: Kiesza

Pop needed a heroine who could sing, dance and handle a rifle. We speak to the sharp-shooting Canadian who answered that call

The best new music of 2014: Nimmo

Get this smart disco-pop duo into your life, as they join our rolling guide to the best new acts around

See all Time Out music features