Frankie Rose – 'Herein Wild' album review

Three years on from her breakout album, the Brooklyn singer struggles to balance the epic and the intimate



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

Frankie Rose is a bona fide indie-pop stalwart. You may know her from her days bashing the drums for various downbeat New York indie bands – Vivian Girls, Crystal Stilts and Dum Dum Girls – or heading up Frankie Rose and The Outs. But it wasn’t until 2012 with ‘Interstellar’ – her first fully independent project as Frankie Rose – that she earned her solo stripes with rave reviews across the board. What it offered was a new, mumble-free sound that channelled soaring ’80s pop and allowed her crystalline voice to take centre stage.

The pressure of expectation weighs heavy on this follow-up. Rose seems to be caught in a confused hinterland, torn between a failsafe formula and a desire for innovation. She has brought in strings to add extra nuance, and at points this is successful - ‘Sorrow’s violin punctuations add a lush, filmic feel, and on ‘Cliffs as High’ the teaming of strings and piano allows for unashamed lashings of Kate Bush melodrama.

The main discord lies in Rose’s seeming desire to maintain these more epic sounds whilst also making space for something smaller and more intimate. For all her efforts, the result is somewhat lacking in conviction – especially when set against her last album. If only Rose hadn’t made ‘Interstellar’ so damn good…

Buy this album here

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Listen to Frankie Rose on Spotify

Users say


Read more music features

The best independent music venues in London

For Independent Venue Week, we’ve rounded up a few of our favourite gig venues

Interview: Gerard Way

The My Chemical Romance singer talks Britpop, Bowie and board games

Ten acts you need to know about in 2015

You’ll be hearing great things from these up-and-coming bands, singer-songwriters, producers and artists throughout this year

The Time Out music quiz 2014

Test your knowledge of the year’s musical highlights, from Kanye and Kim to Kiesza and Kate Bush

The 50 best songs of 2014

Stick this playlist on repeat – it’s the very best new music of the last 12 months

See all Time Out music features