Throughout ‘Since I Saw You Last’ there are clues that Barlow is taking notes from Britain’s pop success stories, old and new. Opener ‘Requiem’ has more than a hint of Sgt Pepper-era Macca; a mid-record lull comes courtesy of Sir Cliff; and in the more up-to-date moments of ‘Let Me Go’ and ‘This House’ there’s a strong whiff of Mumford. The difficulty lies in Barlow’s too finely honed skills as a musical chameleon: despite its presence on a gamut of hits from the last 20 years, his voice is entirely anonymous. This leaves us feeling slightly like we’re being serenaded by a well-suited mortgage advisor.
The eagerly-awaited Elton John duet, ‘Face to Face’, is an all-Elton disco number, and whilst it offers a welcome injection of spangly fun in a largely buttoned-up album, it also serves as a reminder that Gazza lacks even a hint of Elton’s idiosyncratic flair. The high points of ‘Since I Saw You Last’ affirm Barlow’s status as a deft crowd pleaser: ‘God’ could be the closing number in a hit West End show, while ‘More Than Life’ displays the rousing joy of some of Take That’s recent hits. But even in the album’s more exciting moments, Gary sounds a little lonely. It’s hard not to yearn for the ‘ooh’s and ‘aah’s of Robbie and the gang. Buy this album here
What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.