Pixies – 'Indie Cindy' album review

We've waited 23 years for a new album by the legendary Boston band – was it worth it?



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

Here’s the bad news: this is the worst album that the Pixies have ever released. That said, it’s not nearly as bad as it could have been.

Compiling the bits and pieces of new material that the Pixies have released over the last year, ‘Indie Cindy’ is the reunited alt rock titans’ first LP in 23 years – a year longer, even, than it took My Bloody Valentine to follow up ‘Loveless’. But whereas last year’s ‘m b v’ was up there with its creators’ best work, ‘Indie Cindy’ only sometimes comes close to rivalling the gut-punch excitement of Pixies’ shrieking, shredding, euphoric run between 1986 and 1993.

True, opening track ‘What Goes Boom’ growls and thrashes convincingly, and the expansive, wobbling riff on ‘Greens and Blues’ wouldn’t sound out of place on ‘Doolittle’ or ‘Bossanova’. The glam-stomping ‘Blue Eyed Hexe’ is another highlight, echoing David Bowie’s cover of the Pixies’ ‘Cactus’.

But the title track is cringe-inducingly wacky, and there are several songs that tick along too pleasantly, without the abrasive shock and thrill of the band’s classic material. In fact, the whole thing sounds a lot like frontman Black Francis’s (aka Frank Black’s) solo albums. That’s no surprise considering his long-term foil, bassist Kim Deal, left the band last year – apparently because she didn’t see the point in writing any new Pixies material. She might have been on to something.

What do you think of ‘Indie Cindy’? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Buy this album on Amazon  |  Buy this album on iTunes

Listen to 'Indie Cindy' on Spotify

Users say


Read more music features

Top 10 Notting Hill Carnival anthems

Get in the mood with the tunes that have defined Carnival over the years

Interview: Rustie

The shy guy producer on the language of birds and the benefits of recording at 30,000 feet

What's the deal with… Protomartyr

Everything you need to know about the furious foursome from Detroit

50 things you didn't know about Notting Hill Carnival

Get ready for Europe's biggest street party with these little-known facts

Notting Hill Carnival warm-up and after parties

The hottest pre- and post-Carnival parties this August bank holiday

See all Time Out music features