Toy – 'Join the Dots' album review

The London krautgazers may sound as derivative as ever, but their second album is an expansive and satisfying listen



Add +

Time Out Ratings :

<strong>Rating: </strong>3/5

Toy are one of the most promising young bands in London. They’re also one of the hairiest, with ’70s-style mops that hang down over their eyes. That might be why the five-piece can be hard to get a handle on. Are these vinyl-loving retromaniacs indulging in a bit of harmless musical nostalgia, or are their psychedelic krautrock stylings painfully derivative?

This second album won’t do much to change the minds of those who think the latter: ‘Join the Dots’ is full of nods (or hairy headbangs) to the past. There are echoes of shoegaze originators My Bloody Valentine on ‘Endlessly’, along with riffs pulled from krautrock pioneers Neu! on the title track, and a ghostliness gleaned from avant-garde electro-pop band Broadcast on ‘As We Turn’. Even the album sleeve seemingly aspires to conjure up Kreuzberg in 1972.

Judging by the album’s title, Toy are perfectly happy to be seen as connecting points of reference. More importantly, though, the band and their producer Dan Carey have made a quality product. ‘Join the Dots’ is a sleek, shimmering record, full of ramshackle reverb and throbbing bass lines. Those heady influences remain, but in the year since their self-titled debut, Toy have developed a darker and more expansive sound. There’s still a heavy dose of motorik, the hypnotic drumbeat designed to replicate the experience of speeding along an autobahn, but it’s now a nocturnal motorik for driving under the infinite night sky. It’s hard to pick holes in songs this compelling, especially when many crescendo spectacularly into swirling walls of noise.

Plagiaristic? Possibly. Enjoyable? Definitely. Toy represent a bit of the old world, and a bit of the new. And that’s more than okay.

Buy this album here

What are your thoughts? Let us know in the comments box below or tweet us at @TimeOutMusic.

Listen to Toy on Spotify

Watch the video for 'Join the Dots'

Users say


See Toy live in London


  • Critics choice

Scowling like the Stones and riffing like the Stooges, burning through OMD-like

  1. The Garage Highbury Corner, N5 1RD
  2. Thu Oct 30
Buy tickets

Read more music features

Interview: Jamie T

On the eve of his new album ‘Carry on the Grudge’ and two huge gigs, we meet the Wimbledon strummer and comeback kid

What's the deal with… Goat

Here's everything you need to know about Sweden's funky, mask-loving psychedelic crew

Interview: Jessie Ware

The south London soul queen and 'tongue-in-cheek diva' tells us how she stays down-to-earth, and why she never gets bored of love songs

The myth education of Lauryn Hill

As the turbulent star comes to London for four shows, we correct a few rumours about her troubled career

What's the deal with… Jaws

Get your teeth into this up-and-coming four-piece from the Birmingham indie scene

See all Time Out music features