Cookies where you least expect them | Lincoln Park Neighborhood Guide 2011
Wed Jun 1 2011
Photograph: Martha Williams
We’re not complaining or anything, but for years now it’s been impossible to walk three blocks in Lincoln Park without tripping on a cupcake. But here’s a little-known secret: That homeliest of desserts—the simple, satisfying cookie—is all over this ’hood as well. They’ve just been hiding in unexpected places (even—get ready—cupcake shops!).
1220 W Webster Ave, 773-883-1313
Known for Croissants
Unexpected cookie Cornmeal lime sables (50 cents)These small, coinlike cookies, kept in a big glass jar near the cash register, are made to be eaten by the handful.
2521 N Clark St, 312-638-9151
Known for Falafel
Unexpected cookie baklava ($1) With crisp layers of phyllo layered with copious amounts of sugar syrup and nuts, this cookie delivers a flabbergasting dollar-to-sugar ratio.
951 W Armitage Ave, 773-296-9866
Known for Truffles
Unexpected cookie Costa Rican chocolate ($5.50)These hefty chocolate-chip cookies are made in conjunction with Carol’s Cookies and weigh in at approximately a half-pound each.
2464 N Clark St, 773-698-6667
Known for Meatloaf
Unexpected cookie “Signature” cookie ($4) They call it “signature,” but you could also call it “kitchen sink”—the thing is packed with pretzels, M&Ms, dulce de leche, oats and chocolate chips.
2536 N Clark St, 773-883-7220
Known for Cupcakes
Unexpected cookie Ginger molasses ($1.50)Sweet and spicy cookies like the kind you’d find at a bake sale. Which is fitting, since a portion of Molly’s profits is donated to schools.
Sweet Mandy B’s
1208 W Webster Ave, 773-244-1174
Known for Cupcakes
Unexpected cookie Peanut butter ($1.75)Like everything else at this shop, these look and taste like June Cleaver made them: classically soft, rich and sweet.
You might also like
Affordable shopping (really!)
Food for any craving
Bars worth visiting over and over again
Oh, the drama!
Cookies where you least expect them
Lincoln Park Zoo: An adult’s guide
Grilling, boozing, brunching and dancing at 1,208-acre Lincoln Park
A free day in Lincoln Park
Chicago History Museum