New York movies: Gothamites pick their top five NYC-set films
Actors, directors, writers, critics and movie buffs reveal their favorite New York movies.
Tue Jul 3 2012
There are 8 million stories in the Naked City; not all of them have inspired New York movies, but more than 100 have. We've weighed in with our picks, so we canvassed a range of cinephiles—including Ethan Hawke, John Turturro and Ira Sachs—for their favorite NYC-set flicks.
RECOMMENDED: See all 100 best New York movies
Ethan Hawke; actor, writer and director
1. Broadway Danny Rose (1984) "Manhattan and Annie Hall are great, sure, but this Woody Allen film is my top choice."
2. Dog Day Afternoon (1975) "This is an obvious choice, I know, but this is Sidney Lumet and Al Pacino at their finest."
3. Shadows (1959) "Cassavetes's jazz improv is a knockout. Robert Frank's short film 'Pull My Daisy' is a similar jazz tone poem that is also brilliant."
4. Life Lessons (1989) "Scorsese's contribution to the film New York Stories is among the best short films ever made. Is it better than Raging Bull; Taxi Driver; Goodfellas; New York, New York; Gangs of New York; Mean Streets; etc.? Probably not, but if you haven't seen it, you must."
5. Do the Right Thing (1989) "Spike Lee is another hero of New York cinema. Mo’ Better Blues, He Got Game, She's Gotta Have It and Crooklyn are other fantastic New York films, but this was the game changer."
Scott Foundas, associate program director at the Film Society of Lincoln Center
1. The Godfather Part II (1974)
2. Wavelength (1967)
3. Taxi Driver (1976)
4. Broadway Danny Rose (1984)
5. 25th Hour (2002)
Michael Feingold, chief theater critic at The Village Voice
1. Next Stop, Greenwich Village (1976)
2. Manhattan (1979)
3. "A choice of three Sidney Lumet films—I can't decide!—Prince of the City (1981), Dog Day Afternoon (1975), Bye Bye Braverman (1968)"
4. Gold Diggers of 1933 (1933)
5. "Either Easy Living (1937) or Nothing Sacred (1937)"
Runners-up: All About Eve (1950), The Cameraman (1928), Cat People (1982), Cover Girl (1944), Shall We Dance? (1937) and "too many more to count!"
Mike Maggiore, programmer and publicist at Film Forum
1. Goodfellas (1990)
2. Speedy (1928)
3. Sweet Smell of Success (1957)
4. The Taking of Pelham One Two Three (1974)
5. "Under the Brooklyn Bridge" (1955)
See more film lists
Movie moms: The 50 most classic movie mothers of all time
Movies about youth & rebellion: The 50 best youth-gone-wild films
The best and worst James Bond movies: a ranked list
The top 50 sports films of all time
The 100 best films set in New York City
Our 50 favorite film fools
The 50 best uses of songs in movies
The 50 best movie villains of all time
The 50 best food-on-film moments of all time
The 50 most special effects of all time
The 50 greatest war films of all time
The 50 most romantic movies of all time
The 50 most controversial movies ever
The 50 best documentaries of all time
The top 50 foreign films of all time
The 10 most patriotic movies ever
The 30 best summer blockbusters ever
The 50 most-deserving Oscar winners of all time
The TONY top 50 movies of the decade
Top ten movie hairdos