20 of the worst Oscar winners in history

Tom Huddleston sorts the least deserving Academy Award winners

It’s Oscar season once again – and while Academy members scratch their heads trying to decide which of this year’s crop of worthy titles deserves to take home the big prize, we trawl the archives to uncover the worst Oscar offences of all time. From the film that beat ‘Citizen Kane’ to Best Picture to the time ‘Harry and the Hendersons’ walked away with a handful of gold, here are all the Academy’s biggest blunders in one handy list.

This is by no means a definitive rundown of all of Oscar’s shoddy decisions – we didn’t even have room to mention Celine Dion or ’Chicago’ – so if you really, really hate ‘Titanic’ or really, really love ‘Forrest Gump’, tell us about it in the comments box below.

10. ‘Out of Africa’ (1986)

Best Picture, 58th Academy Awards, 1986

In the mid-'80s, the Academy suddenly became obsessed with dishing out heaps of awards to grandiose, sweeping tales of life in foreign lands: see ‘Gandhi’, ‘Platoon’, and ‘The Last Emperor’. While each of those films is defensible, the same can’t really be said of this tiresome, glacially-paced colonial romance.

It could’ve been: Witness’, ‘Ran’ (not nominated), ‘Prizzi’s Honor’.




Browse through our list of Oscar blunders

Victor Fleming for 'Gone with the Wind' (1939) 'How Green was My Valley' (1941) 'The Greatest Show on Earth' (1952) 'Around the World in 80 Days' (1956) Leon Shamroy for 'Cleopatra' (1963) 'The Sound of Music' (1965) 'Une Homme et une Femme' (1966) John G Avildsen for 'Rocky' (1977) 'I Just Called to Say I Love You' by Stevie Wonder (1985) 'Out of Africa' (1986) Rick Baker for 'Harry and the Hendersons' (1988) 'Driving Miss Daisy' (1990) Anthony Hopkins for ‘The Silence of the Lambs’, Al Pacino for ‘Scent of a Woman’ Three drippy ballads from Disney 'Forrest Gump' (1994) 'A Beautiful Mind' (2002) Renee Zellweger for ‘Cold Mountain’ (2003) 'Crash' (2006) 'The Secret in Their Eyes' (2010) Mauro Fiore for 'Avatar' (2010)

Check out our UK film release calendar

Share your thoughts
  1. * mandatory fields

Comments & ratings

Rated as: 0/5 (0 ratings)
  • Almost every movie that won in the 80s was the wrong choice. Around the world in 80 days is a joke. The secret in their eyes was a great movie though. and while how green was my valley is not a terrible movie cant believe it beat out citizen kane

    Ken Wed Nov 21 2012
    Report
  • I can't take anyone who thinks that Mulholland Drive is a better film than A Beautiful Mind seriously.

    Drew Sun Nov 18 2012
    Report
  • <a href=http://ja-obcan.info/forum/profile.php?id=363275> I recommend to you to come for a site where there are many articles on a theme interesting you.</a>

    icon library Sun Nov 4 2012
    Report
  • What about Tom Hanks as Best Actor for Philadelphia instead of Anthony Hopkins for Remains of the Day, Anthony Hopkins for Shadowlands, Daniel Day-Lewis for In The Name of The Father or Liam Neeson for Schindler's List? OR Tommy Lee-Jones as Best Supporting Actor for The Fugitive over Leonardo DiCaprio for What's Eating Gilbert Grape?

    The Squiss Thu Sep 27 2012
    Report
  • And then there's Kenneth Branagh being nominated for Best Adapted Screenplay for the unexpurgated Hamlet! www.thesquiss.co.uk

    The Squiss Thu Sep 27 2012
    Report
  • This is a really clever list I have to admit. Forrest Gump, with its predictable story, did not deserve the Oscar, that was rightfully Tarantino's for Pulp Fiction. On the other hand, Rocky winning best Picture and Director was bad enough. Network and Taxi Driver really did deserve the wins. And why is not Titanic in the list? It did not deserve the Oscar at all. Also, Slumdog Millionaire.... not worthy as well. Avatar- best cinematography- Oscar was playing a big joke on the audience.

    Zoeb Tue Sep 18 2012
    Report
  • Add: Sandra Bullock (being nominated is bad enough) winning, Julia Roberts, Slumdog Millionaire, War Horse getting nominated, most anything by Steven Spielberg, actually; also add: James Cameron, Extremely Loud being nominated, The Help (a feel good movie for anglo Americans about a cruel and trying time where there was little to feel good about), Aaron Sorkin, Inception being nominated, Denzel Washington for Training Day, any nomination or award for Ron Howard, the best picture to Lord of the Rings final installment.....and so many more....I think the point is that they get more things wrong than they do right....why? B/c it is comprised of people from within the very industry that gives them jobs so they want to maintain the status quo for the most part; it is a reflection of what American audiences (for the most part) react to, which is not necessarily the best made film; and b/c The Academy has a identity struggle, trying- like a chile, or The Supreme Court- to maintain legitimacy and all too often shedding any sense of legitimacy by caving into bad hollywood overwrought melodrama...cue the Batman music b/c its next on the caravan of bad films to get nominated in 2013.

    Ay Mon Aug 6 2012
    Report
  • It is extremely egregious for you to say Anthony Hopkins and Al Pacino didn't deserve their Oscars. Those were two amazing performances, especially Hopkins's performance-simply chillng. And playing a blind man while delivering that performance is very difficult. Number 13 is really outrageous. And that comment on Gone With the Wind is just plane stupid. And Driving Miss Daisy, while a snub, isn't one of the worst. The Oscars are the highest achievement in film industry. And saying they're a load of crap is basically saying that Ledger winning best actor in Dark Knight is a load of crap; The Godfather winning best picture is a load of crap; Nicholson winning best actor for Cuckoo's Nest is a bunch of crap. So the Academy Awards are not a load of crap.

    will Sun Jul 29 2012
    Report
  • the deer hunter was a sorry movie

    Patsy Sat Apr 14 2012
    Report
  • the sorriest movie i have ever seen was babel

    patsy brown Sat Apr 14 2012
    Report
  1. 1
  2. 2
  3. 3
  4. 4
  5. 5
  6. 6
  • Hotwise
  • Cool brands
  • Star