The 50 greatest war films of all time

Fall in for TONY's list of mighty military movies.

By David Fear, Joshua Rothkopf and Keith Uhlich Thu May 26 2011

War films: They Were Expendable (1945)
War films: MASH (1970)
War films: Sergeant York (1941)
War films: Army of Shadows (1969)
War films: Come and See (1985)
War films: Starship Troopers (1997)
War films: Full Metal Jacket (1987)
War films: Grand Illusion (1937)
War films: Apocalypse Now (1979)
War films: Paths of Glory (1957)

War films: They Were Expendable (1945)

They Were Expendable (1945)

The kind of film that can force you to revise your idea of whole careers—even decades of work—this assiduous, unshowy portrait of the fighting men of the Philippines builds a quiet impact out of small, keenly observed moments. Our heroes, mainly John Wayne's junior-grade lieutenant, wind away the small hours in Manila, waiting for an assignment to the fight. They don't realize, of course, that these are the good times; when news comes of the attack on Pearl Harbor, the tone shifts to one of a stoic ode to workmanlike sacrifice. Director John Ford, normally a sentimentalist behind the camera, reigns in his impulses, while Wayne (still closer to dewy at this point) shows depths that hadn't been tapped.—Joshua Rothkopf

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

MASH (1970)

With the U.S. mired in the seemingly endless horrors of Vietnam, what better time was there for something as biting and hilarious as Robert Altman's Korean War satire? The director's biggest hit of his career, like Kubrick's Dr. Strangelove before it, gave audiences the chance to snicker at strife: The narrative follows members of a Mobile Army Surgical Hospital—standouts include Donald Sutherland's Hawkeye and Elliott Gould's Trapper John—as they make anarchic mischief (usually of the spy-on-the-girl-in-the-showers variety) in between gory operations. No target is sacred; even The Last Supper is recreated with gleeful blasphemy. (If you only know the TV show, see where all the high jinks began.)—Keith Uhlich

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Sergeant York (1941)

No truly great war film will ever strike a tone of total conviction; that's the realm of imperialist propaganda. Howard Hawks's massively popular drama (released only months before America's entrance into WWII) takes the exact opposite tack: It's the story of real-life First World War soldier Alvin York, a Tennessee simpleton who hoped to avoid enlistment on the sincere grounds of his religiosity and pacifism. His request denied, York proves himself on the battlefield as a singularly talented sharpshooter and wrestles with the killing gift God has given him. Gary Cooper's tortured performance won him an Oscar and continues to inspire a conversation about situational ethics.—Joshua Rothkopf

Buy on Amazon

Army of Shadows (1969)

Rediscovered in 2006 with the fanfare usually reserved for unearthing a lost classic (which was pretty much the case), Jean-Pierre Melville's cool-blue portrait of French Resistance fighters makes a beautiful case for honor among wanted men. Back-room beatings and drive-by shootings spark a mostly conversational film about the sacrifice of spies. Melville's reputation had previously rested on chilly, remote gangster pictures like Le Samoura (1967), but to see his canvas widened to national politics was a revelation. And the reason the movie had been ignored in the first place? Fashionable French critics had dismissed it as too pro-De Gaulle. What comes around...—Joshua Rothkopf

Buy on Amazon

Come and See (1985)

It's likely you'll want to avert your eyes during Russian director Elem Klimov's terrifying WWII epic about the Nazi occupation of Belarus. Yet it weaves a mesmerizing spell, from the opening image of two children digging in a field for abandoned rifles. One of those boys is taken from his home by partisans to fight the Germans. It's the start of a nine-circles-of-hell odyssey that culminates with a dreamlike encounter with the ultimate persecutor. But before that finale, we're subjected to a staggering succession of atrocities (ear-shattering explosions, corpses piled high, a village systematically destroyed) that would be unbearable were it not for the film's entrancing, near-surreal aesthetic.—Joshua Rothkopf

Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Starship Troopers (1997)

Stop snickering: There's a real reason why this sci-fi actioner is so high on our list. Never before (and probably never again) had the monied apparatus of Hollywood been so co-opted to make a subversive comment about its own fascist impulses. Director Paul Verhoeven cackled all the way to the box office as giant bugs were exterminated by gorgeous, empty-headed bimbos; when Neil Patrick Harris showed up near the end of the movie in a full-length Nazi trench coat, the in-joke was practically outed. Source novelist Robert Heinlein meant his militaristic tale sincerely; meanwhile, the blithe destruction of humankind on display here could only be intended as a sharp critique, both of soldiering and of popular tastes. Return to it with fresh eyes.—Joshua Rothkopf

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Full Metal Jacket (1987)

Stanley Kubrick's unnerving contribution to Vietnam war movies will gouge out your eyes and skull-fuck you (to quote a line). The first half of this opus, set at the Marines' Parris Island training facility, is widely lauded: Drill instructor R. Lee Ermey spouts every imaginable expletive (plus some new ones) while putting a group of new recruits through their paces. Yet the less-discussed second half—which follows Matthew Modine's Pvt. "Joker" and his fellow soldiers through the Tet Offensive—is a necessarily complement. This is where we see the end result of turning men into killing machines, and it's like gazing into the abyss.—Keith Uhlich

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Grand Illusion (1937)

Jean Renoir, the great humanist of cinema, cowrote and directed this superlative WWI story about two French aviators who are captured by a German captain (Erich von Stroheim, perfectly cast as a mannerly despot) and shuttled between prisons. The duo plans a great escape, but this isn't a simple tale of heroes and villains. Class conflict is prevalent: One of our heroes is an aristocrat and easily befriends his warden. The other, meanwhile, is a rough-hewn everyguy—a charismatic ranter against the system. Yet Renoir places no one character above another. Indeed, the film is sympathetic to all perspectives, even as it sagely questions how these combative circumstances came about. For its pointed generousness, the movie was awarded numerous prizes and earned the ire of Joseph Goebbels who declared it "Cinematic Public Enemy No. 1."—Keith Uhlich

Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Apocalypse Now (1979)

The battles behind Francis Ford Coppola's surreal war movie are well-documented: the nightmarish, multiyear shoot; star Martin Sheen's heart attack and recovery; a cackling press corps that sharpened its knives for a turkey of epic proportions. Coppola would have the last laugh. So much of the vocabulary of the modern-day war picture comes from this movie, an operatic Vietnam-set tragedy shaped out of whirring helicopter blades, Wagnerian explosions, purple haze and Joseph Conrad's colonialist fantasia Heart of Darkness. Fans of the Godfather director, so pivotal to the 1970s, know this to be his last fully realized work; connoisseurs of the war movie see it (correctly) as his second all-out masterpiece.—Joshua Rothkopf

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

Paths of Glory (1957)

And so we've reached the top of the top, the ultimate statement on man's inhumanity to man. Is it any surprise that it comes from Stanley Kubrick? So much of the director's filmography was devoted to depicting military folly (and believe us, we toyed with including Barry Lyndon, too). Elevating Paths of Glory above the fray—and above every other title—was not its brutal scenes of WWI trench warfare but its scalpel-scarp indictment of the pride that comes with battle. Kirk Douglas's lawyer-colonel is tasked with mounting a courtroom defense of three innocent soldiers who just happened to be part of a losing skirmish. Based on a real-life episode of French soldiers executed for "cowardice," Kubrick's movie so angered France's government that it couldn't be screened publicly there until 1975. The film's lesson is universal and timeless, though: If warfare turns us into monsters even off the battlefield, then we have no purpose waging it.—Joshua Rothkopf

Watch now on iTunes Watch now at Amazon Instant Video

See more in Film

« previous
next »

Your rating
Name *
Email *
Comment *
* mandatory fields

Comments & ratings

(25 ratings)

I find strange not to see a classic war film like "Glory" in this list. I guess is not as moving or important as Starship Troopers. LOL

Mimo About 22 hours ago
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
Wtf no saving private Ryan what a joke for a list

Kyle About 2 days ago
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
It is easy to condemn “fascist impulses”, but it isn’t so easy to portray war as it is really is--a natural development of human behavior that has been with us since we displaced the Neaderthals. I find such critiques of war like “Troopers” to be simple regurgitations of beliefs that are ignorant of history. They also are hypocritical. Th director would not have been able to make such a film if not for the sacrifices men willing to fight and die so we may have the freedom to make films like “Starship Troopers”. While I do agree that glorifying war and its accoutrements is repugnant we also must be aware that our freedoms and rights were earned on the field of strife, not in the peaceful fields of Elysium. Give me nuanced depictions of war like “Letters from Iwo Jima” any day over pseudo-intellectual bilge like “Starship Troopers”.

ryan About 3 days ago
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
The Longest Day, Breaker Morant, In Harm's Way, The Battle of Britain Red Badge of Courage. All better than Starship Troopers Also Enemy at the Gates,

Joe O'Donnell About 7 days ago
Rated as: 3/5
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
I Think Saving Privet Ryan Should be in the top 10 if not #1

Dylan About 10 days ago
Rated as: 1/5
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
I agree w/ several of the comments below. To put Starship Trooper even on this list over the Victors, They Came To Cordura, For Whom the Bells Toll, Sand Pebbles, 55 Days in Peking, Seven Samari, the Big Parade, Gettysburg, and probably at least 50 more.

Gunnar W About 11 days ago
Rated as: 2/5
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
This list is bonkers. Hurt Locker and Star Ship Trooper in the Top 10 but no Lawrence of Arabia, Schindlers List, Bridge Too Far, We Were Soldiers, Full Matal Jacket, Letters from Iwo Jima, Downfall? Had the author been drinking or is this meant to be controversial? And I think Twelve O'cloch High Warrants a place in the top 10.

Jonathan Bywater Wed May 1
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
Is Schindler's list not considered a war film? Along that same line, how bout The Counterfeiters?

Ronnie D. Mon Apr 29
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
Most of the list was accurate but alot of listed "greatest movies" were not so great. Starship troopers? Seriously? Why happened to wind talkers, we were soldiers, the patriot, brave heart ?

Sean Army Veteran Sun Apr 28
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *
A decent list, but "Starship Troopers"????? Uh-uh, too self-serving

Anthony Forsman Thu Apr 25
Report
1. Name *
2. Email *
3. Reason *