1. Village Party Store
Enter for floor-to-ceiling costumes, props, gizmos and party supplies! This classic party store may have had an unfortunate experience with a fire back in 2010, but it's certainly back in action with more cool stuff than ever. You'll find everything from amazing masks to Halloween candy baskets to party favors and gag gifts. Village Party Store is also known for having ultra-helpful staff, which may be harder to find at some of the chains in town. Need balloons? They've got those too. 13 E 18th St (212-675-9697, villagepartystore.com)