The 30 greatest American family dramas

American playwrights know how to keep it in the family.

  • Photograph: Carol Rosegg

    RAISED IN CAPTIVITY

  • Photograph: Blaine Davis

    LEAR

  • Photograph: James Leynse

    CROWTET

  • Photograph: Alicia Donelan

    THE EFFECT OF GAMMA RAYS ON MAN-IN-THE-MOON MARIGOLDS

  • Photograph: Michal Daniel

    TOPDOG/UNDERDOG

Photograph: Carol Rosegg

RAISED IN CAPTIVITY

Raised in Captivity

30. RAISED IN CAPTIVITY
The overbearing matriarch is to family drama as bloodletting is to Jacobean tragedy: inevitable, if usually overdone. Still, no one creates toxic moms like Nicky Silver (now heading to Broadway with The Lyons). Silver’s archly absurd 1995 comedy begins with a description of a mother’s death by hurtling shower-massage attachment, and gets stranger (and sadder) from there. Imprisonment is the apt, operative metaphor for Silver’s portrayal of the Bliss family (in an ironic wink to Noël Coward) and several of the impish playwright’s archetypes are present and accounted for: chronically celibate brother; crazy, self-obsessed sister; and soul-eating mother.—DC

Lear

29. LEAR
Young Jean Lee trampolines her devastating postdramatic construction off Shakespeare’s ultimate tragedy, King Lear, using the Elizabethan text to launch her own excruciating deconstruction of grief. Playful and biting, Goneril, Regan and Cordelia snipe at one another; sulky and competitive, Edgar and Edmund mope. Lee’s mean-girl courtiers suddenly give way, though, to women tortured by an inability to sufficiently love their parent, and the fourth wall tinkles into dust. By the strange third act—which quotes the Sesame Street gang explaining death to Big Bird—we realize that we’re in the presence of a playwright contemplating a father’s death and trying, rather desperately, to help us do the same.—HS

Secondhand Smoke, part of Mac Wellman's Crowtet

28. CROWTET
High priest of the postmodern language play Mac Wellman wrote his quartet A Murder of Crows, The Hyacinth Macaw, The Lesser Magoo and Second-Hand Smoke as a series of unpeeling layers (he called it the “exegesis of the spiritual state of the Onion”) around a certain emptiness—the family drama. In Wellman’s discombobulating darkness, we stumble across Susannah—prophet, daughter to a walking dead man and hater of war—who abandons her human family to live among the crows. His satire, one infinitely regressive and difficult to label, takes ornery delight in puncturing the nation of “the Rational Biped.”—HS

The Effect of Gamma Rays on Man-in-the-Moon Marigolds

27. THE EFFECT OF GAMMA RAYS ON MAN-IN-THE-MOON MARIGOLDS
Paul Zindel was a science teacher in his midtwenties when he wrote this tenderly morbid slice of Staten Island gothic, in which a deranged mother torments her two daughters and their unfortunate rabbit. Six years after the play’s 1964 premiere in Houston, it moved to New York and won a surprise Pulitzer Prize for its quirky mixture of hopelessness and adaptive optimism, and Zindel went on to a long and successful career as the author of idiosyncratic books for young adults.—AF

Topdog/Underdog

26. TOPDOG/UNDERDOG
Suzan-Lori Parks took the frequently used metaphorical equivalency between family and America and turned it into this scarifying 2002 portrait of two African-American brothers named, portentously, Lincoln and Booth. An astringent burlesque of race, kinship and masculinity, Topdog/Underdog shows us America as a fairground jungle, a place where two black men—a kind of Cain and Abel enslaved by the almighty dollar—hustle three-card monte in a bid to finally realize some interest on their country’s half-hearted investment in Emancipation.—HS

Share your thoughts
  1. * mandatory fields

Comments & ratings

Rated as: 4/5 (4 ratings)
  • Great list. but there is one great play missing: Tennessee Williams' A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE!!! I don't know why you didn't include it.

    NewKeith16 Sat Jun 2 2012
    Rated as: 3/5
    Report
  • Surprised not to see Next to Normal on this list.

    Rebecca Wed Apr 4 2012
    Report
  • Thanks for the comment, Francis. But I think your count is slightly off: I see three African-American families (Fences, Raisin, Topdog) plus one by an Asian-American playwright that was originally cast as African-American (Lear). What Asian or Latino or Native American plays would you propose we had included in lieu of the ones on this list?

    Adam Feldman Thu Mar 29 2012
    Report
  • 30 family plays. 28 white families. 2 African American families. Absolutely no representation of Asians, Latinos, Native Americans. Rather than this list, I'd love TimeOut to write an article about diverse playwrights.

    Francis Jue Thu Mar 29 2012
    Report
  • For the most part they are all about dysfunctional families so what are we saying with this when we call them the greatest "Family" plays? - - - - I actually agree with the choices but we are glorifying conflict and pain. And where is "The Royal Family" or "You Can't Take It With You" , "Ah Wilderness?' - - Oh well Many will scream at me.

    Don Fleming Wed Mar 28 2012
    Rated as: 3/5
    Report
  • Our Town ain't really a family drama.

    Cecil Ripley Wed Mar 28 2012
    Rated as: 4/5
    Report
  • Hi Howard: Thanks! Yes, as I note in the introduction to the list we were aware that many of top 10 are older works. I think it may be that genre might have had its heyday in the last century... but who knows what the next 50 years will bring?

    David Cote Wed Mar 28 2012
    Report
  • Cool list- I have seen about half and read about 2/3 ---Thanks, you just gave me some summer reading to help me paint myself a bigger picture ... :)

    Coni Ciongoli Koepfinger Wed Mar 28 2012
    Rated as: 5/5
    Report
  • A well-reasoned list. It is interesting, however, that of your “Top 10,” the most recent is some 25 years old. Does this indicate a change in focus by playwrights, or that no recent plays measure up to the standards you set?

    Howard Sherman Wed Mar 28 2012
    Report
  • A GREAT LIST, BUT YOU NEGLECT EARLIER TREASURES, SUCH AS O'NEILL'S TOO OFTED UNDERRATED AH WILDERNESS, SIDNEY HOWARD'S THE SILVER CORD, I REMEMBER MAMA, AND ELMER RICE'S STREET SCENE, NOT TO MENTIO SUCH MUSICALS AS HIGH BUTTON SHOES.

    alfred Wed Mar 28 2012
    Report
  1. 1
  2. 2