100 best NYC songs: Nos. 10–1

Watch music videos for iconic NYC songs by Leonard Cohen, Ryan Adams, Lou Reed and more.

0

Comments

Add +

10. Leonard Cohen, "Chelsea Hotel No. 2" (1974)

Cohen's disarmingly tender reference to a blow job from Janis Joplin still shocks, but that's not what makes this song such an enduring portrait of NYC bohemia. When he sings, "Those were the reasons/And that was New York/We were runnin' for the money and the flesh," he doesn't come off as a perv so much as a sad, old poet, memorializing his own bygone wild days and the ones who didn't make it through theirs. If the Chelsea Hotel still retains any of its heady cachet (which was later unpacked with wry brilliance by Jeffrey Lewis in "The Chelsea Hotel Oral Sex Song"), we have this magical ballad to thank.—Hank Shteamer

Chelsea Hotel No. 2 - The Best of Leonard Cohen

Play "Chelsea Hotel No. 2" on Spotify



9. Ryan Adams, "New York, New York" (2001)

Modern-day balladeer Ryan Adams shot the devastatingly gorgeous video for this New York City hymn of praise against a backdrop that would change forever just four days later, when the Twin Towers were destroyed. The Grammy-nominated single from his excellent Gold album remains a fierce declaration of love, as well as a courageous rallying cry from a city recovering from loss and pain.—Marley Lynch

New York, New York - Gold

Play "New York, New York" on Spotify



8. Grandmaster Flash and the Furious Five, "The Message" (1982)

Hip-hop existed before this breakthrough single dropped; still, with unprecedented prominence given to Grandmaster Flash's harrowing narrative over the Furious Five's slow groove, "The Message" arguably marks the birth of rap as we know it. The clear-eyed and explicit lyrics still pack a punch; in the repeated line "Don't push me/'Cause I'm close to the edge," you can sense the desperation of a neighborhood, a culture and a generation.—Steve Smith

The Message - The Message

Play "The Message" on Spotify



7. Leonard Bernstein with the Columbia Symphony Orchestra, "Rhapsody in Blue" (1959)

Gershwin was just 25 years old when he wrote this genre-bending composition for piano and jazz orchestra in 1924. A sublime collage of melodies and rhythms, the piece conjures the throb and clang of Jazz Age urban life so evocatively that it has become an aural signifier for New York City itself. The piece was notably used in the opening montage of Woody Allen's Manhattan and in the Hirschfeld-inspired sequence in Disney's Fantasia 2000.—Adam Feldman

Rhapsody in Blue - Gershwin: An American In Paris

Play "Rhapsody in Blue" on Spotify



6. Lou Reed, "Walk on the Wild Side" (1972)

This deathless Lou Reed cut paints a wise, sympathetic portrait of the misfits, hustlers and junkies drawn like flies to New York City, where every outsider can find a sliver of acceptance, if not outright redemption. Even the track's signature sound—tubby acoustic bass tangled with slinky, fretless electric—was a hustle: In a 2005 interview, session player Herbie Flowers (who played both instruments) claimed he was just trying to make twice the cash.—Steve Smith

Walk On the Wild Side - Transformer

Play "Walk on the Wild Side" on Spotify



RECOMMENDED
Live photos: Leonard Cohen at Radio City Music Hall
See which of Moby's top ten NYC songs made our list



5. Billie Holiday, "Autumn in New York" (1952)

The bruised optimism of Vernon Duke's much-covered 1934 jazz standard—which allows that a New York autumn is "often mingled with pain," but insists that "it's good to live it again"—found its perfect expression in Billie Holiday's yearning version with pianist Oscar Peterson. Duke's moody music and poetic lyrics ("Glittering crowds and shimmering clouds in canyons of steel") are an invitation to fall in love.—Adam Feldman

Autumn In New York - Billie Holiday

Play "Autumn in New York" on Spotify



4. LCD Soundsystem, "New York, I Love You but You're Bringing Me Down" (2007)

From an album that inspired a critical love-in came a video that starred Kermit the Frog, for a song that LCD Soundsystem chose to close its farewell show. Its charms are many; A downtempo, half-shrugged first verse turns into a punch-by-punch slugfest by the song's end—the perfect equivalent to any New Yorker's relationship with the city we love to hate and hate to love. Besides appealing to city dwellers' nostalgia, it addresses trivial concerns ("Take me off your mailing list"), along with some big ones ("Our records all show you were filthy but fine"). And why is it all so infuriating? New York knows we'll never break up with her: "You're still the one pool where I'd happily drown."—Sophie Harris

New York, I Love You But You're Bringing Me Down - Sound of Silver

Play "New York, I Love You but You're Bringing Me Down" on Spotify



3. Beastie Boys, "No Sleep Till Brooklyn" (1986)

Like the Beasties themselves, this Licensed to Ill anthem runs on a mixture of local pride and adolescent obnoxiousness. Slayer guitarist Kerry King backs the three MCs as they take turns chronicling the lifestyles of the young, rich and tasteless on the road ("Got limos, arenas, TV shows/Autograph pictures and classy ho's"). They also drop in a reference to "cold kickin' it live" at MSG, just so you know they've risen to the top of the local heap as well.—Hank Shteamer

No Sleep Till Brooklyn - Licensed to Ill

Play "No Sleep Till Brooklyn" on Spotify



2. Frank Sinatra, "Theme from New York, New York" (1980)

The city's unofficial anthem sees New York through the wide eyes of an outsider: a small-town striver hoping that "If I can make it there, I'll make it anywhere." The song breathes aspiration, and is itself a fairly recent arrival: Broadway's John Kander and Fred Ebb wrote it for Liza Minnelli to sing in 1977's New York, New York (a film set in the '40s), and Frank Sinatra made it famous three years later. Even though it's not quite "A-number-one, top of the list" in our rankings, it remains the quintessential paean to "old New York," city of dreams, where brand-new New Yorkers arrive every day.—Adam Feldman

Theme from New York, New York - Nothing But the Best - The Frank Sinatra Collection (Remastered)

Play "Theme from New York, New York" on Spotify



1. Jay-Z with Alicia Keys, "Empire State of Mind" (2009)

Of all the world's glitzy capitals, New York is the one that's truly the city of dreamers. Rough-and-tumble is putting it mildly, as the city's rich musical history attests. But from its many knocks, something amazing emerges. When Jay-Z's roll-with-the-punches verse gives way to Alicia Keys's chorus, it's the musical equivalent of the first time you touched down on the JFK tarmac or saw the Statue of Liberty. "Empire State of Mind" is hopeful and warm—and for that reason, it's the only song to provide a real update to Sinatra's "New York, New York." We'll take it.—Sophie Harris

Empire State of Mind - The Hits Collection, Vol. One (Deluxe Edition)

Play "Empire State of Mind" on Spotify



RECOMMENDED
Live photos: LCD Soundsystem's final show
Interview: Adam Yauch of the Beastie Boys
Live photos: Jay-Z holds court at Madison Square Garden



100–91 | 90–81 | 80–71 | 70–61 | 60–51 | 50–41 | 40–31 | 30–21 | 20–11 | 10–1


See the full list of 100 best NYC songs

See more in Music

Users say

0 comments