Song for Marion

Film, Drama
  • 3 out of 5 stars
  • 3 out of 5 stars
(2user reviews)
0 Love It
Save it
Song for Marion

A marvellously insightful portrait of male emotional reticence lurks within an otherwise doggedly conventional feelgood drama in this change of pace for writer-director Paul Andrew Williams (‘London to Brighton’, ‘Cherry Tree Lane’). He puts two cash-strapped pensioners at the heart of this film, and it proves one of his smartest moves. It allows a first-ever on-screen pairing for actors Terence Stamp and Vanessa Redgrave, and it puts genuine mortality at stake when illness jeopardises her role in a community choir for senior citizens. Redgrave is affectingly bright and breezy as the lively granny determined to make it to a national choral competition, while Stamp digs in as the grumpy other half who’s scornful of her activities. He’s not one for joining in anything.

Fate – and formulaic plotting, needless to say – has other ideas. But even though we know where the film’s going, it still manages to give the tear-ducts a workout. That’s in spite of a lumpy sub-plot involving estranged son Chris Eccleston, who’s too like his old dad to get on with him, and some toe-curlingly contrived acapella pop (Motörhead! Salt-N-Pepa!) from the assembled oldies. Williams’s better instincts are on display, however, when offering ailing Redgrave a heart-shredding solo number, and also in his attuned writing for the curmudgeonly hubby, whose tender side only his wife sees. So often framed as an icon of patrician cool, Stamp touchingly allows us to share the vulnerable feelings behind those chiselled cheekbones and still-azure eyes, drawing on his own humble roots to deliver a career-highlight performance. And that, surely, is worth singing about.

By: Trevor Johnston


Release details

Rated: PG
Release date: Friday February 22 2013
Duration: 93 mins

Cast and crew

Director: Paul Andrew Williams
Cast: Gemma Arterton
Christopher Eccleston
Vanessa Redgrave
Terence Stamp
1 person listening
mrs o's wizard sleeve

Enjoyable film and I'd forgotten what a gem of a song True Colours is, far more moving than Stamp's song finale. Stamp however is grumpy but tender.. Film did feel a but twee in parts and I'd love to know what part of London it was filmed in as it was totally chav and litter free!..


I would totally agree with the review. At times the singing is a bit cringing but at the centre of the film are a number of wonderful performances. Redrave and Stamp are up to the high standard you would expect from such experienced stars. However it is Arterton who seems to spend the whole film in outfits designed to make her look dowdy who steals the film as the teacher come cheerleader for the OAP singers whilst deep down having her own struggles. I defy you not to cry if you see it. A film they wouldn't have made a few years ago before the studios realised that it wasn't just the 15 to 35's who went to the cinema. A film that has a story to tell and tells it well. Solid 7 out of 10 a good 3 stars for me.