Get us in your inbox


  • Film

Time Out says

Some terrible urban disaster has occurred. The injured are rushed to hospital, a mass of labyrinthine corridors, rundown, dimly lit. A doctor sarcastically asks blowsy nurses puffing at fags whether they’re bored. The soundtrack chugs with stabbing chords. Revealing that it’s all an exercise manned by volunteers, a medic sings out, ‘Emergency over!’ – and sings is the word.

From now on, all dialogue is sung. Kornél Mundruczó’s film is an opera. It’s also – allegedly – a retelling of the passion of Joan of Arc. Johanna (Osolya Tóth), a young drug addict, becomes a nurse in the Kafkaesque hospital and hits on a novel method of healing: sleeping with patients. This apparently works for everything, including liver complaints. The patients unsurprisingly approve and, rather more startlingly, consider her a saint. Nasty nurses are jealous; the young head doctor loves her but her rejection sparks a chain events leading to civil war between patients and staff and fleeting philosophising about God and creation.

Zsófia Tallér’s music veers between the lyrical and the declamatory, with a military flavour for the choruses of Johanna’s fans and foes. The language alternates between ethereal (‘Don’t follow me – I am made of crystal’) and prosaic (‘Let’s run to the urology!’), both baffling. The moral is punched home with Brechtian directness: ‘Think twice if you want to be good… Better to be a murderer than a saint.’ The cinematography of Mátyás Erdély and András Nagy creates a nightmare subterranean world whose images linger after the sound and the (not very furious) fury have died away.
Written by Martin Hoyle

Release Details

  • Rated:15
  • Release date:Friday 29 September 2006
  • Duration:83 mins

Cast and crew

  • Director:Kornél Mundruczó
  • Screenwriter:Kornél Mundruczó, Yvette Biro, Viktória Petrányi
  • Cast:
    • Orsolya Tóth
    • Ildikó Cserna
    • Istvan Ganter
    • Dénes Gulyás
    • Zsolt Trill
You may also like
You may also like