Time Out says
Imagine Richard Curtis adapting Bake Off and you’re close to the sugar high of this slice of cinematic comfort food
It’s easy to be sniffy about a film that sets three friends on an against-all-odds quest to set up Notting Hill’s 400th artisanal bakery, but there’s enough winning ingredients in this slight but sweet-natured comedy-drama to defy cynicism. The ever-watchable Celia Imrie, for one, who brings enough salty detachment to all the pastry porn and feelgood vibes to keep it all from collapsing under the weight of its own sugariness like some kind of rogue soufflé. The film’s themes of inclusion, family and multiculturalism may be broadly delivered, but they definitely don’t all miss the mark.
Imrie plays Mimi, a retired trapeze artist – go with it – whose daughter Sarah (a cameo from The Great British Bake Off winner Candice Brown) is tragically killed cycling to recce the premises for a new café she plans to set up with her best pal Isabella (Shelley Conn). Mimi’s granddaughter Clarissa (Beast’s Shannon Tarbet), a drifting wannabe ballerina who smokes too much weed to make pirouetting a long-term career prospect, finds the spark of an idea amid the trio’s grief, gloom and general estrangement: what if they set up the place anyway and named it after Sarah?
Enter Sarah’s dishy ex (a roguish Rupert Penry-Jones), a pastry chef who knows his millefeuille from his madeleine and may or may not be Clarissa’s father. They’ve got the goods but can they lure in the crowds? As Bill Paterson’s Heath Robinson-esque inventor and security specialist (no one in this privileged ensemble has a normal job) wonders: ‘There are four other bakers within five minutes’ walk. What makes yours so special?’
It’s smart of first-time screenwriter Jake Brunger’s script to ask this obvious question so directly and smart of director Eliza Schroeder to answer it by clutching the city’s ethnic diversity to her movie’s heart. While Love Sarah is set in a chocolate-boxy west London, full of quaint mews, dance studios and cutesy boutiques – think Richard Curtis-land, only without all the grit and urban squalor – it’s also a place of community, congregation and diversity. What in normal times might grate – hey, we’re all outsiders together in this vast metropolis! – feels like a timely reminder that actually, we kinda are. Or it might just feel like a Remainer fantasia, depending on your political persuasion.
In the spirit of full disclosure, this masthead features strongly in the plot and it’s tough to be too harsh on a movie that re-avows the earth-shattering significance of a glowing Time Out review. But while Love Sarah is too narratively thin to warrant one of those, its sweetness lingers a little longer than you’d expect.
Out in UK cinemas on Fri Jul 10.
Cast and crew