Time Out says
For a film whose title evokes new beginnings, this portrait of five people devastated by the 2001 terrorist attacks treads dangerously close to necrophilia. Intercutting decade-spanning interviews of the quintet with time-lapse footage of the in-progress Freedom Tower being built, this documentary treats the attacks with a brain-shrinking piousness more befitting a memorial dedication than a work of cinema. Even as the subjects detail the processes of grieving, healing and moving on, Whitaker continually strikes a tone of reverent mawkishness, further contributing to the notion that 9/11's legacy continues to be one of easy, knee-jerk sentiment rather than wider understanding.
Follow Andrew Schenker on Twitter: @aschenker