4 out of 5 stars
LIFE OF BRIAN Gregory tries to keep up with the Jones
LIFE OF BRIAN Gregory tries to keep up with the Jones.

Time Out says

4 out of 5 stars

A quick-talking convict (Norton) up for parole is willing to do anything to get his strict case officer (De Niro) to let him out---including faux-finding religion and using his comely wife (Jovovich) to seduce the sad-sack authority figure. Surely we've already seen this movie, right? But John Curran (The Painted Veil) lets viewers know early on that he could give a toss about making a typical who's-conning-who thriller; all ye searching for Primal Fear redux, abandon hope. The character-driven drama he offers viewers instead is something far more complex, cracked and unique for an American movie boasting big-name stars: an unblinking glare into the abyss.

Neither Stone's ambient white-noise soundtrack (courtesy of Jon Brion and Radiohead's Jonny Greenwood, both uncredited) nor Norton's rusty-door Detroit accent can drown out the keening pitch of the movie's central irony---why does one "bad" man have a genuine epiphany, while a "good" one goes into a moral free fall? The seesaw effect of the characters' clarity and confusion helps Curran & Co.'s unexpected, occasionally heavy-handed fumblings toward examining spiritual emptiness find purchase. That the film often cuts bone-deep, however, can be almost single-handedly credited to one actor.

Robert De Niro is synonymous with Method-actor-as-rock-star performances, yet there's little showboating in the way he plays this remote everyman---only numbness, inarticulacy, and a desperate grasping for answers that feels both raw and frighteningly real. It's easily the best work he's done in a decade, a triumph not of acting but of real, honest-to-God acting; you not only forget you're watching an icon, you feel as if you're truly witnessing someone burdened with decades of emotional baggage psychically crumble before your eyes.



Release details

Cast and crew